{"id":181,"date":"2020-08-13T08:50:21","date_gmt":"2020-08-13T08:50:21","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/?page_id=181"},"modified":"2021-09-22T16:53:10","modified_gmt":"2021-09-22T16:53:10","slug":"2020-wang","status":"publish","type":"page","link":"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/2020-wang\/","title":{"rendered":"Lifestyles, Knowledge, and Cultural Products: Fujian Daily-Use  Encyclopedias of the Late-Ming Dynasty and Their Painting and  Calligraphy Sections"},"content":{"rendered":"\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Wang Cheng-hua (Princeton University)<sup>1<\/sup><br>Translated by Michael Day<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Originally published as: Wang Cheng-hua (Wang Zhenghua). \u201cShenghuo,  zhishi yu wenhua shangpin: wan Ming Fujianban riyong leishu yu qi  shuhuamen\u201d \u751f\u6d3b\u77e5\u8b58\u8207\u6587\u5316\u5546\u54c1\uff1a\u665a\u660e\u798f\u5efa\u7248\u65e5\u7528\u985e\u66f8\u8207\u5176\u66f8\u756b\u9580in Zhongyang yanjiuyuan Jindaishi  yanjiusuo jikan \u4e2d\u592e\u7814\u7a76\u9662\u8fd1\u4ee3\u53f2\u7814\u7a76\u6240\u96c6\u520a (Journal of the Institute of Modern  History, Academia Sinica) 41 (September 2003): 1-85.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<h2 class=\"wp-block-heading\" id=\"daily-use-encyclopedias-on-the-late-ming-1368-1644-book-market-editing-strategies-and-potential-readers\">Daily-Use Encyclopedias on the Late-Ming (1368-1644) Book Market: Editing Strategies and Potential Readers<\/h2>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">The prolific publishers of Jianyang, Fujian, flooded the prosperous \nbook market of the late-Ming dynasty with a wide variety of texts \u2014 \neditions of the Confucian Classics, histories, poetry collections, \nmedical works, <em>fengshui<\/em> guides, classical tales, vernacular \nnovels and stories, dramas, etc. Of all these works, scholars have been \nparticularly intrigued by Jianyang\u2019s \u201cdaily-use encyclopedias\u201d (<em>riyong leishu<\/em>\n \u65e5\u7528\u985e\u66f8), works purporting to provide all readers with the practical \ninformation they needed in their everyday lives. Many have taken this \npurpose, stated frequently in the encyclopedias\u2019 prefaces and even in \ntheir titles, at face value, using them as evidence for the \nreconstruction of daily life in early modern China. This essay tests the\n validity of this assumption by analyzing the compilation strategies, \ncontents, and formats of the late-Ming Fujian daily-use encyclopedias, \nparticularly as they compare to daily-use encyclopedias of different \nperiods and regions, in order to understand their place in the \nstratified book market and, finally, to determine their potential \nreadership. Useful to this understanding is an examination of the \ncharacteristics of Fujian daily-use encyclopedias like <em>Santai\u2019s Infinitely Useful [Guide to] How to Do Everything Correctly<\/em> (<em>Santai wanyong zhengzong<\/em> \u4e09\u53f0\u842c\u7528\u6b63\u5b97, 1599), <em>Five Carts of Select Marvels<\/em> (<em>Wuche bajin<\/em> \u4e94\u8eca\u62d4\u9326, 1597), and <em>Deep Ocean of Myriad Books (Wanshu yuanhai<\/em> \u842c\u66f8\u6df5\u6d77, 1610), all products of the very late sixteenth and early seventeenth centuries.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">The earliest extant daily-use encyclopedia, Chen Yuanjing\u2019s \u9673\u5143\u975a <em>Expansive Record of the Forest of Affairs<\/em> (<em>Shilin guangji<\/em>\n \u4e8b\u6797\u5ee3\u8a18), was published centuries earlier, in the late Southern Song \ndynasty (1127-1279). The original edition has been lost, but it survives\n in the form of a series of editions, which circulated widely throughout\n the Yuan (1279-1368) and Ming dynasties. Two different lineages of Yuan\n dynasty editions are extant, one from 1330-1333 and one from 1340, as \nwell as at least eight Ming dynasty editions; these editions were \nprinted and distributed by local governments as well as commercial \npublishers. Chen Yuanjing, a failed examination candidate who, having \ngiven up on an official career, went to work as an editor for a \npublisher-bookseller, was from Chong\u2019an, a town near Jianyang.<sup>2<\/sup> All the extant Yuan and Ming dynasty commercial editions of <em>Expansive Record of the Forest of Affairs<\/em> originate in Fujian, demonstrating that the publication was a regional product.<sup>3<\/sup>\n Although some additions and deletions were made across these many \neditions, the differences mostly affect the arrangement of information, \nwhile the contents remain largely the same; the Ming dynasty editions \nbasically follow the Yuan editions and are divided into the 1330-1333 \nand the 1340 lineages.<sup>4<\/sup>\n All the extant editions that can be clearly identified as Ming editions\n (some do not specify publication dates or publishers) were published in\n the early to mid-Ming dynasty; the latest edition was the 1541 edition \npublished by the Jianyang Yu \u4f59 family Jingxiantang \u656c\u8ce2\u5802 publishing house.<sup>5<\/sup><\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Although <em>Expansive Record of the Forest of Affairs<\/em> was still\n being reprinted in the late Ming, its circulation was limited. \nReplacing it in popularity was a new kind of daily-use encyclopedia, \npublished \u2014 also by the Jianyang publishers \u2014 in thirty varieties; these\n up-and-coming publications stepped in to fulfill the new demands of the\n book market in rapidly changing times.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">A detailed study of these works shows that the <em>Expansive Record of the Forest of Affairs<\/em>\n and the Fujian daily-use encyclopedias of the late Ming are to some \nextent related, firstly in their widespread use of illustration, and \nsecondly in the duplication of detailed content among them. As early as \nthe Song dynasty (960-1279), the Fujian booksellers began to include a \nlarge number of pictures, maps, and charts; <em>Expansive Record<\/em> \nrepresents a fairly advanced stage in this development, with \nillustrations such as \u201cConfucius at the Xingtan Pavilion,\u201d depicting \nConfucius sitting beneath a tree and strumming a lute in the company of \nten disciples (Figure 1).<\/p>\n\n\n\n<figure class=\"wp-block-image\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" width=\"521\" height=\"770\" src=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image2.png\" alt=\"\" class=\"wp-image-183\" srcset=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image2.png 521w, https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image2-203x300.png 203w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 521px) 100vw, 521px\" \/><\/figure>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Figure 1: \u201cConfucius at the Xingtan Pavilion,\u201d from <em>Expansive Record of the Forest of Literati, Newly Edited, Illustrated, and Expanded, and Divided into Categories<\/em> (<em>Xinbian zuantu zengxin qunshu leiyao Shilin guangji<\/em>\n \u65b0\u7de8\u7e82\u5716\u589e\u65b0\u7fa4\u66f8\u985e\u8981\u4e8b\u6797\u5ee3\u8a18), fascicle 4. Duplicate of Xiyuanjingshe woodblock \nedition held by the Fu Ssu-nien Library of the Institute of History and \nPhilology, Academic Sinica, Taipei.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">The late-Ming texts, as we shall see, were even more heavily illustrated.<sup>6<\/sup> Another indicator of the connections between these works is the frequent repetition of certain <em>Expansive Record<\/em>\n entries \u2014 such as \u201cTerritorial Records,\u201d \u201cNational Capitals of the \nPast,\u201d \u201cMiscellaneous Records of Tributary Lands,\u201d \u201cTips for Looking at \nPaintings,\u201d \u201cOn Evaluating Paintings,\u201d and \u201cFu Xiying Evaluates \nPaintings\u201d \u2014in the Jianyang late-Ming daily-use encyclopedias. Regional \ntradition appears to have played a role in this repetition.<sup>7<\/sup><\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">But, although these late-Ming daily-use encyclopedias follow some of the conventions set by <em>Expansive Record,<\/em>\n there are marked differences between the texts. Nearly every fascicle \n(juan \u5377) of every late-Ming Jianyang text contains pictures and \nillustrations, pairing text and graphics in a way that outshines the \nExpansive Record. For instance, while the section on painting in \nExpansive Record consists solely of text, the later encyclopedias add \nnumerous illustrations, so that the top register of a page consists of \ntext and the bottom is made up of pictures; in the \u201cFarming and \nSericulture Section\u201d (\u201cNong sang men\u201d \u8fb2\u6851\u9580), for instance, the Expansive \nRecord includes three illustrations at the start of the section, but \nlate-Ming daily-use encyclopedias employ illustrations on each page, \nwith text on a top register and pictures on a bottom register, a method \nthat clarifies the information presented. This dual register format, \nalready in use in the Tang dynasty (618-907), was a defining \ncharacteristic of many Jianyang publications.<sup>8<\/sup>\n Illustrations increased not only in quantity, but more significantly in\n complexity, comprising a new approach to page formatting. The layout of\n Fujian daily-use encyclopedias of the late Ming heavily emphasized \nvisual impact, and special layouts were designed for many entries for \nease of viewing and browsing. In the \u201cWriting\u201d (\u201cWenhan\u201d \u6587\u7ff0) and \n\u201cCorrespondence\u201d (\u201cQizha\u201d \u555f\u5284) sections, for instance, although there was\n no need for the illustration of sample forms of address and \ncalligraphic scripts, the late-Ming works consistently provided pictures\n that distinguish visually the different forms so that readers \nimmediately see the differences (Figure 2).<sup>9<\/sup><\/p>\n\n\n\n<figure class=\"wp-block-image\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" width=\"425\" height=\"713\" src=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image3.png\" alt=\"\" class=\"wp-image-184\" srcset=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image3.png 425w, https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image3-179x300.png 179w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 425px) 100vw, 425px\" \/><\/figure>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Figure 2: \u201cModel Forms of Address\u201d from the \u201cWriting\u201d section of <em>Five Carts of Select Marvels,<\/em> in <em>Ch\u016bgoku nichiy\u014d ruisho sh\u016bsei,<\/em> 1:310.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\"> The advantages of the above-mentioned formats are that they provide \nspace for more content, simplify layouts, and reduce costs. If the goal \nwas to reduce costs, however, it made no sense then to add \nillustrations, because these visually impactful designs entailed a high \ncost in time and labor, even if crudely engraved. Why, then, did the \nlate-Ming Jianyang daily-use encyclopedias, which depended for success \non high quantity and low prices, make use of them? Perhaps layouts with \ntext on the top and pictures on the bottom were favored not only because\n they provided more room for text, but because they clarified the \nclassification and arrangement of entries, creating a clear and \nconsistent visual effect. Pictures, special formats, and illustrations \nmay also make searching and browsing a text easier, helping users to \nlocate quickly the entries they wish to consult. Given the lively \ninterest in visual impact in the late Ming; given the suitability of the\n two-register layout to the times; given the vogue for illustrated \nserial fiction; and given the circulation of images in a wide range of \nmedia, these daily-use encyclopedias might not have survived on the \nmarket without striking images and an eye-catching format.<sup>10<\/sup><\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">In one other important way, late-Ming daily-use encyclopedias differ from the <em>Expansive Record of the Forest of Affairs.<\/em>\n They considerably reduce content on traditional ideas and practices, \nwith especially drastic cuts to sections on Confucianism, childhood \neducation, and agriculture.<sup>11<\/sup> For instance, the sections of the <em>Expansive Record<\/em>\n on the ancient sages list the names of more than a hundred famed \nhistorical figures, including the seventy-two disciples of Confucius; \nand the section on Confucianism offers instruction in the six \ntraditional scholarly arts (ritual, music, archery, chariot-driving, \ncalligraphy, mathematics) as well as the elements of Confucian teaching \n(e.g., righteous thinking, cultivation of the self and family, \nstatecraft) that candidates were required to know to pass the lowest \nlevel of the civil service examinations. But the late-Ming daily-use \nencyclopedias omit all this material. On the topic of traditional \nagriculture, only the section on farming and sericulture remains, and \nsuch topics as flowers, fruits, plants, trees, livestock, and so on are \nomitted. <em>Expansive Record<\/em> depicts a comprehensive picture of \nagricultural life, but the late-Ming daily-use encyclopedias retain only\n the most basic information, presenting a greatly reduced range of \nmaterial.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">What replaces this information in the late-Ming daily-use \nencyclopedias? They focus on human relations, providing information \nhighly relevant to social intercourse. Sections treat terms of address, \nletter formats, and other protocol for interpersonal interaction and \ndiscuss many types of amusements and social niceties. Expansive Record \nof the Forest of Affairs presents information on cultured pastimes and \nentertainments enjoyed by the literati such as music, calligraphy, \npainting, drinking games, board games, etc. under the category \n\u201cLiterature and Arts\u201d (\u201cWenyi\u201d \u6587\u85dd). Although the late-Ming daily-use \nencyclopedias include information on these topics, they are preoccupied \nwith group amusements such as social drinking and joke-telling, shifting\n the focus from literature and art to pure entertainment. It is easy to \nimagine that, at a boisterous social gathering, the \u201cSocial Drinking \nSection\u201d (\u201cYoushang men\u201d \u4f91\u89f4\u9580) of these works could be employed to \nenliven a round of liquor with guests, and the news and jokes of the \n\u201cWit and Conversation Section\u201d (\u201cXiaotan men\u201d \u7b11\u8ac7\u9580) could heighten an \natmosphere of levity. Late-Ming daily-use encyclopedias fill multiple \nfascicles on the topic of \u201cResources for Conversation,\u201d presenting, in \naddition to the jokes and topics in the \u201cWit and Conversation\u201d section, \nhistorical tales, details of legal cases, and moral advice, all as \nfodder for conversation. And sections on riddles, poems, and romance, \netc. provide information relevant to social interaction on special \noccasions and at particular celebrations. The \u201cPoetry Section\u201d (\u201cShidui \nmen\u201d\u8a69\u5c0d\u9580) includes model antithetical couplets and poems with four, five,\n and seven characters per line, presenting poetry not only as a way of \nencouraging interaction at social occasions, but also as an important \nmeans of everyday interpersonal socialization at special events such as \nbirthdays, weddings, and so on \u2014 indeed, the presentation of \noccasion-appropriate poetry or rhymed couplets was de rigueur at such \ncelebrations. Whereas the \u201cElegant Tales of Romance\u201d entry in Expansive \nRecord of the Forest of Affairs features love stories, the late-Ming \ndaily-use encyclopedias provide \u201cAdvice on [Visiting] Courtesan Houses\u201d \u2014\n that is, how to conduct oneself when visiting prostitutes and picking \nup women. In the late-Ming dynasty, a time when courtesan houses (<em>qinglou<\/em>\n \u9752\u6a13) were important urban social venues, and courtesan culture was a key\n element of urban culture, knowledge of prostitutes showed that one was \nclearly an urbanite \u201cwho knew the ways of the world.\u201d<sup>12<\/sup><\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">It is thus apparent that what was seen as valuable knowledge and a desirable lifestyle in the <em>Expansive Record of the Forest of Affairs<\/em> underwent a drastic transformation in the late-Ming dynasty. Traditional knowledge of the sort found in <em>Expansive Record<\/em>\n centered on the goal of personal moral cultivation, with an emphasis on\n learning and scholarship in general, but also manifesting a particular \nconcern with study associated with the lowest level of the civil service\n examinations, and on the knowledge and lifestyle associated with \nagriculture and rural living. In selecting what to reproduce from the <em>Expansive Record,<\/em>\n the compilers of the late-Ming Jianyang daily-use encyclopedias favored\n the practical portions of the work, but also made significant changes \nto these portions, adapting them to suit contemporary social conditions \nand focusing on social interaction very much within an urban cultural \nsetting.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">In addition to the <em>Expansive Record,<\/em> other early daily-use encyclopedias circulated during the late-Ming dynasty. The Yuan dynasty <em>Complete Collection of Essential Household Knowledge<\/em> (<em>Jujia biyong shilei quanji<\/em> \u5c45\u5bb6\u5fc5\u7528\u4e8b\u985e\u5168\u96c6) was reprinted numerous times during the Ming dynasty by both local governments and commoners.<sup>13<\/sup>\n One extant Ming-dynasty edition includes a 1560 preface by Tian Rucheng\n \u7530\u6c5d\u6210 (?-ca. 1540), a prolific writer well-known enough to receive a \nmention in the orthodox history of the dynasty, the <em>History of the Ming<\/em> (<em>Ming shi<\/em> \u660e\u53f2).<sup>14<\/sup>\n The preface sets out to confirm the book\u2019s origins, discussing the \nreasons for its publication and asserting its authenticity. Tian holds \nthat the information on youth education, filial piety, and ritual \npropriety in <em>Essential Household Knowledge,<\/em> as well as its \nmaxims for government officials and self-cultivation, are of a high \nstandard, suited for reference in both household and government \nadministration and of use in cultivating moral character, regulating \nfamilies and administering states.<sup>15<\/sup>\n A comprehensive survey of the book bears out this description of its \ncontents. Within the framework of Confucian ethics, it instructs elite \nfamilies in how to administer their households and function as \nofficials, apparently appealing to readers who were the heads of \neducated households. The first chapter of the book is entitled \u201cEngaging\n in Study\u201d (\u201cWeixue\u201d \u70ba\u5b78) and discusses educational methods for the \nyounger generation, covering everything from manners to reading and \nwriting. It is obviously not intended for reading by the children \nthemselves, but by the parents primarily responsible for their \neducation. The \u201cFamily Rules\u201d (\u201cJiafa\u201d \u5bb6\u6cd5) section covers marriage and \nfuneral rites, citing Sima Guang\u2019s \u53f8\u99ac\u5149 (1019-1086) famous \u2014 and rigidly \northodox \u2014 <em>Miscellaneous Domestic Rituals<\/em> (<em>Jujia zayi<\/em> \u5c45\u5bb6\u96dc\u5100).<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">The \u201cEngaging in Study\u201d and \u201cFamily Rules\u201d sections demonstrate that <em>Essential Household Knowledge<\/em>\n was intended for use by elite families; the contents of sections on \nbureaucratic history were clearly selected with educated classes in \nmind. Nonetheless, the book includes numerous entries of a highly \npractical, instructional nature, encompassing such subjects as raising \npoultry and cattle, cultivating vegetables and fruits, identifying \nmedicinal ingredients, pickling vegetables and preserving health and \nfitness. None of this information is related to scholarship or Confucian\n household management \u2014 what are we to make of its inclusion in a book \nclearly intended for the elite? A closer look at the contents of these \nsections shows that they treat the needs of practical household \nmanagement \u2014 that is, they discuss methods of managing family farm life \nfor male heads of household; they are directed to readers who are not in\n fact farm laborers but estate managers. It is thus clear that this \npractical lifestyle guidance would support the non-commercial lifestyles\n of the rural gentry, who owned land and family enterprises; and, at the\n same time, facilitate the passage of the lowest level of the civil \nservice examination by the heads of household or members of the younger \ngenerations \u2014 and thus perhaps their appointment as government \nofficials.<sup>16<\/sup><\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\"><em>Essential Household Knowledge<\/em> was repeatedly reprinted \nthroughout the Ming, and it is apparent that there was a market for the \nwork even in the late Ming. In addition to this work, numerous other \ndaily-use encyclopedias, similarly devoted to the Confucian principle of\n \u201ccultivating the self, regulating the family, governing the state, and \nbringing peace to the world,\u201d circulated throughout the mid-to-late Ming\n dynasty. <em>Song\u2019s Family Essentials, Household Rites, Family Regulations, and Leisure [Activities]<\/em> (<em>Songshi jiayao jiayi jiagui yanxian bu<\/em>\n \u5b8b\u6c0f\u5bb6\u8981\u90e8\uff0c\u5bb6\u5100\u90e8\uff0c\u5bb6\u898f\u90e8\uff0c\u71d5\u9592\u90e8), edited by Song Xu \u5b8b\u8a61 in 1504, is another example. \nSong\u2019s preface explains clearly that the work is guided by the \nprinciples of entry-level Confucian studies (that is, the basic \nConfucian teachings the mastery of which could earn one <em>shengyuan<\/em>\n \u751f\u54e1 status, the lowest of the examination ranks) and that it aspires to \nhelp regulate the family in order to fulfill these principles \u2014 and \npresumably earn <em>shengyuan<\/em> status, which came with certain \nsocial and economic privileges. In addition to proper family rules and \netiquette, the content encompasses all sorts of practical knowledge \nrequired for management of prosperous families of some education, \nincluding, for example, health tips, information on farming and \nsericulture, and descriptions of various types of account books for \nkeeping track of real estate, valuables, and livestock. The work is \nclearly intended for gentry families who owned land and perhaps managed \nrural businesses.<sup>17<\/sup><\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Household Essentials (Jujia bibei \u5c45\u5bb6\u5fc5\u5099), published in the late-Ming \ndynasty by the Dushufang \u8b80\u66f8\u574apublishing house, was also intended to \nfulfill the family administration and business management needs of the \nelite. It is graced with a preface by famed early-Ming scholar and poet \nQu You \u77bf\u7950 (1341-1427), <sup>18<\/sup>\n who declares that the main undertakings of a household are teaching \nchildren, making a living, and governing the family \u2014 in other words, he\n sets forth an image of a traditional Confucian family engaged in both \nwork and study similar to that presented by both Song Xu and Tian \nRucheng. The target audience is obviously the educated elite, as the \nwork contains texts written by noted authors from Southern Song dynasty \nauthor Zhao Xigu \u8d99\u5e0c\u9d60 to late-Ming dynasty authors Tu Long \u5c60\u9686 (1542-1605)\n and Wen Zhenheng \u6587\u9707\u4ea8 (1585-1645) as well as well-known late-Ming works \non aesthetics and the good life, such as Shen Hao\u2019s \u6c88\u9865 (1586-?) On \nPainting (Hua zhu \u756b\u9e88) and Gao Lian\u2019s\u9ad8\u6fd3 (fl. 16th c.) Eight Treatises on \nthe Nurturing of Life (Zun sheng ba jian \u5c0a\u751f\u516b\u7b8b).<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\"><em>Household Essentials<\/em> (and most likely the Ming editions of <em>Collected Essentials of Household Knowledge<\/em> and Song Yu\u2019s <em>Song\u2019s Family Essentials<\/em>)\n was published, not in Jianyang, but in the Jiangnan region (the lower \nYangzi river delta), whose major cities were the major sites of commerce\n and culture in the late Ming \u2014 and several hundred kilometers away from\n Jianyang, Fujian. It was published at least twice, once in the 1620s by\n Duan Jingting\u2019s \u6bb5\u666f\u4eadDushufang, a prolific publishing house in Hangzhou, \none of the great cities of Jiangnan; and once by the Xinyuantang \u5fc3\u9060\u5802, \nmost likely also located in the Jiangnan region.<sup>19<\/sup>\n Although the Jianyang, Fujian, publishers and the Jiangnan publishers \nproduced, generally speaking, the same types of books and marketed them \nin the same places, late-Ming publications from Fujian reveal the Fujian\n publishers\u2019 exclusive focus on market considerations. They did not care\n for quality or improvement, but valued, rather, speed of production and\n affordability, aiming to attract a mass audience. They profited richly \nfrom this calculation, but the results of their choices are apparent in \nthe relatively low production qualities of their daily-use \nencyclopedias.<sup>20<\/sup><\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">The three daily-use encyclopedias above, all of which focus mainly on\n household administration, can be distinguished from Fujian \nencyclopedias not only in terms of their contents, but also in terms of \ntheir layout; in the latter regard, they are poles apart. <em>Household Essentials<\/em>\n consists mostly of text, includes few illustrations, and employs a \nloose, expansive layout with large characters and a consistent page \nformat lacking top and bottom registers. In contrast, as indicated \nabove, the Fujian daily-use encyclopedias are full of illustrations, and\n pages are divided into upper and lower registers. Character size \nvaries, and the texts are not necessarily easy to read. And, in <em>Household Essentials<\/em>\n and similar texts, when earlier writings are reproduced in the text, \ntheir sources are noted, and the texts are reproduced relatively \ncompletely. Fujian daily-use encyclopedias, on the other hand, copy only\n fragments of texts and insert them into disparate sections. Thus, not \nonly are the reproductions fragmentary, they are removed from their \noriginal contexts, which are never cited.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Contrasts in both contents and layout indicate that these \npublications served different purposes. Daily-use encyclopedias for the \nliterati elite were meant for study purposes, and thus provided readers \nwith complete original texts and presented a full range of information \non each topic. For instance, the \u201cEngaging in Study\u201d section of <em>Household Essentials<\/em>\n provides comprehensive information ranging from how to teach children \nto put on clothes and walk down the street to letter-writing formats to \nbe used once they were able to read. The inclusion of information on \nwriting in this section shows that its purpose is the edification and \nacademic advancement of civil service examination candidates. By \ncontrast, the way in which Fujian daily-use encyclopedias present the \n\u201cCalligraphy\u201d (\u201cCalligraphy\u201d\u66f8\u6cd5) section shows that they did not envision\n calligraphy as a necessary part of a Confucian education: they placed \nit among all the other sections, with no indication of which is more \nimportant or which section should be associated with a higher goal (e.g.\n Confucian education). They treat calligraphy just as they treat social \ndrinking, jokes, and romance \u2014 it is just one other form of everyday \ninformation the reader might consult if he\/she desires. Even the \narrangement of the tables of contents makes it apparent that Fujian \ndaily-use encyclopedias are meant for browsing \u2014 the reader was not \nexpected to read every character. Each section is listed in a standard \ntwo-character title like \u201cCalligraphy\u201d or \u201cPainting Manual (\u201cHuapu\u201d \u756b\u8b5c);\n then beneath the title, entries in the lower and upper registers are \nlisted separately, in four-character titles; for instance, the \u201cPainting\n Manual\u201d section is divided into an upper \u201cPainting Tips\u201d register and a\n lower \u201cPainting Manual Essentials\u201d register. Beneath these titles are \ndetailed notes in small characters, providing plenty of topics for \nconversation \u2014 a reader perhaps might get all he or she needed just from\n the table of contents (Figure 3).<\/p>\n\n\n\n<figure class=\"wp-block-image\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" width=\"438\" height=\"697\" src=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image4.png\" alt=\"\" class=\"wp-image-186\" srcset=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image4.png 438w, https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image4-189x300.png 189w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 438px) 100vw, 438px\" \/><\/figure>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Figure 3: Table of contents from <em>Five Carts of Select Marvels,<\/em> in <em>Ch\u016bgoku nichiy\u014d ruisho sh\u016bsei,<\/em> 1:11.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">The table of contents of <em>Essential Household Knowledge,<\/em> in \ncontrast, indicates the order of entries clearly, and it is apparent \nwhich entries belong to which sections; for instance, the information on\n Confucian education is presented in a logical step-by-step sequence, \nbut no consideration is given to visual ease of reference.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">In the mid-to-late Ming dynasty, daily-use encyclopedias of this nature continued to be produced.<sup>21<\/sup>\n The greater proportion of their contents was dedicated to agricultural \ninformation and the concerns of rural life, an orientation that \ndifferentiated them sharply from the urban-centered Fujian daily-use \nencyclopedias. But there was also another kind of daily-use encyclopedia\n that must be distinguished from the Fujian works. The prime example is \nthe well-known <em>Assembled Illustrations from the Three Realms: Heaven, Earth, and Man<\/em> (<em>Sancai tuhui<\/em>\n \u4e09\u624d\u5716\u6703), published in 1609. This encyclopedia was closely associated with\n the elite scholarly class. Its editor, Wang Qi \u738b\u573b (1530-1615), earned \nthe highest civil service examination degree. The work itself includes \nprefaces by a number of noted officials, literati, and scholars. <em>Assembled Illustrations from the Three Realms<\/em>\n presents a complete system of knowledge, illuminated with copious \nillustrations. One of the prefaces praises it as a \u201clavishly illustrated\n work\u201d that revives the classical tradition of learning. Another preface\n makes a point of distinguishing it from popular encyclopedias and \ncommercially produced texts. Although such works circulate so widely \nthat \u201ca train of oxen would perspire under their collective weight,\u201d as \none preface explains, their many pages and many entries amount to little\n more than \u201cfodder for jokes\u201d \u2014 a remark that might have been aimed at \nthe Fujian daily-use encyclopedias. <em>Assembled Illustrations from the Three Realms,<\/em> in contrast, presents orthodox Chinese knowledge through a combination of illustration and text<sup>22<\/sup>;\n it is not at all like the daily-use encyclopedias of the Fujian \nbooksellers, with their truncated citations and piecemeal presentation \nof information. In production quality, too, <em>Assembled Illustrations of the Three Realms,<\/em> with its exquisite illustrations and meticulous block engraving, far surpasses the Fujian products.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">In sum, daily-use encyclopedias published in Jianyang, Fujian have \ncharacteristics that distinguish them from other daily-use encyclopedias\n intended for either a rural gentry or a sophisticated literati \naudience. They targeted a different, well-defined market segment, and \nobviously, given their popularity, succeeded in meeting a certain need \namong contemporary readers. Both their layout and contents indicate that\n they were designed for reference and to supply conversation fodder, not\n for scholarly study. They stand apart from traditional imprints made up\n exclusively (or almost exclusively) of text; their emphasis on visual \ndesign and illustration was aligned with the contemporary interest in \nvisuality. Their anticipated readership was not the traditional Chinese \nsocial elite, the literati and scholars. Nor was the lifestyle they \npromoted that of the landed rural gentry \u2014 that is, they did not assume a\n life of studying and farming (and perhaps running household \nenterprises) \u2014 but rather a lifestyle with a profoundly urban character.\n Although buyers of late-Ming Fujian daily-use encyclopedias did not \nnecessarily reside in cities, the editing strategies of these books were\n obviously influenced by the widespread appeal of urban culture; the \nworks themselves manifested the cultural impact of urban prosperity.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Who purchased and read these works? The most direct way to determine \nwho bought and consulted the Fujian daily-use encyclopedias is naturally\n to look at book prices and purchasing power. The list prices of two \ndaily-use encyclopedias, one tael (<em>liang<\/em> \u5169) and one mace (<em>qian<\/em> \u9322), give us a rough idea of the price range; the work costing one <em>liang<\/em> was ten times the price of the work that sold at one mace.<sup>23<\/sup>\n Among late-Ming book prices, one mace is inexpensive and one tael is \naverage. Books selling at high prices were usually exquisitely printed \neditions of famous works or heavily illustrated works; they might cost \nas much as two or three taels. By contrast, the prices of daily-use \nencyclopedias were near the bottom of the book market.<sup>24<\/sup><\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Some scholars argue, however, that these prices placed the works \nbeyond the reach of the lower classes of society, who simply did not \nhave the purchasing power to buy books even at the price of one mace. \nOthers, comparing book prices to the salaries of government officials, \nargue, too, that ordinary people could not afford any books at all, even\n those at the lower end of the market.<sup>25<\/sup>\n The salary records of government officials are not, however, the best \ngauge of people\u2019s ability to purchase books in the late Ming. The real \nsalaries of government officials exceeded what was on record; various \ntypes of unofficial income and extralegal kickbacks raised the figures \nfar in excess of the salaries listed in official records. Moreover, the \nincomes of other social classes and occupations in the late Ming were \nnot related to the salaries of various classes of officials. That the \nbook market flourished in the late Ming indicates that books were an \nimportant component of contemporary cultural consumption; in an age of \neconomic development and burgeoning consumption, families with money to \nspend did so, often on daily-use encyclopedias.<sup>26<\/sup><\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Although, because of the lack of relevant sources, it is difficult to\n determine precisely which people or groups of people read late-Ming \ndaily-use encyclopedias, some clues provide food for speculation. In the\n seventeenth-century vernacular novel <em>A Marriage to Awaken the World<\/em> (<em>Xingshi yinyuan zhuan<\/em>\n \u9192\u4e16\u59fb\u7de3\u50b3), set in the late Ming, there is a minor character, Chao Yuan, \nthe wastrel son of the family of a rural county magistrate. He is \ncompletely uninterested in classical studies and able to read only \nchildren\u2019s books like the elementary primer <em>Thousand Character Classic<\/em> (<em>Qianzi wen<\/em>\n \u5343\u5b57\u6587). One day the young man suddenly falls ill and a doctor comes to \ntake his pulse. In need of a book on which to rest his patient\u2019s arm, \nthe doctor requests a copy of <em>Directory of Officials<\/em> (<em>Jinshen lu<\/em>\n \u7e09\u7d33\u9304), but the servant girl returns with a book of pornographic prints \nand an erotic novel. When the doctor looks askance at these, she changes\n them for a daily-use encyclopedia, <em>No Need to Seek Advice on Myriad Matters<\/em> (<em>Wanshi bu qiu ren<\/em> \u842c\u4e8b\u4e0d\u6c42\u4eba).<sup>27<\/sup>\n Clearly the author believed that daily-use encyclopedias did not \nrequire a high level of education, necessitating only the ability to \nread the <em>Thousand Character Classic<\/em>, that is, they were accessible to \u201cpeople with a crude level of literacy.\u201d<sup>28<\/sup>\n Furthermore, Chao Yuan\u2019s collection includes pornography as well as \ndaily-use encyclopedias \u2014 that is, it is made up of works of idle \nentertainment befitting his immature personality and habit of reading \nless-than-respectable books.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\"><em>A Marriage to Awaken the World<\/em> is set in Wucheng, Shandong, \nand Huating, Jiangsu, seeming to indicate that distribution of Fujian \ndaily-use encyclopedias extended both north and south of the Yangzi \nRiver. Although we lack detailed records of print runs, sales numbers, \nand marketing networks, scholars, through painstaking research on the \nFujian publishers and the bookshops they managed, have concluded that \nsome of them most likely sold their products not just in Fujian, but \nalso in the major cities of the Jiangnan region \u2014 Nanjing in particular \u2014\n and even in the capital, Beijing, far to the north. Publishers like Yu \nXiangdou \u4f59\u8c61\u6597 (1550?-1637), perhaps the most prolific of the Fujian \npublishers, were fully familiar with the publishing business in Nanjing \nand repeatedly reprinted \u201ccapital editions\u201d (<em>jingben<\/em> \u4eac\u672c) \u2014 that\n is, works published in the capital, suggesting that there was \ncirculation of works between at least two different publishing sites. \nSome scholars claim that in the late Ming, central and southern Chinese \nbook markets were integrated, and circulation of daily-use encyclopedias\n was not limited to Fujian. The book market in Fujian province could not\n compare with that of the flourishing, culturally advanced Jiangnan \nregion, and Jianyang (Fujian) booksellers could not earn sufficient \nprofits from sales to the literate population of Fujian alone. The \nJiangnan region was likely the biggest market for books from Fujian.<sup>29<\/sup><\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Because of the lack of sources, it is difficult to determine either \nthe absolute numbers or the proportion within the general population of \nthe so-called \u201cpeople with a crude level of literacy\u201d in the late Ming. \nHowever, scholars generally agree that the literate population increased\n at that time as a result of economic development. Although no study has\n found the increase to be higher than ten percent, it nonetheless had a \nsignificant impact on contemporary society and cultural production; and \nmight have also stimulated the proliferation of new publications.<sup>30<\/sup>\n Other researchers have emphasized the role of \u201cfunctional literacy\u201d in \nthe Ming and Qing, pointing out that ordinary people uninterested in \nofficial service or scholarly advancement did not need to attain high \nlevels of literacy; they might learn to read enough to provide for their\n everyday needs, but never be able to compose presentable prose. Certain\n professionals \u2014 doctors, fortunetellers, geomancers, accountants, \nprofessional letter-writers, officiators at religious ceremonies such as\n weddings and funerals, etc. \u2014 had to be able to read basic characters. \nThese people, who today would be called \u201ctechnicians\u201d or \u201cspecialists,\u201d \nwere common in Chinese cities and villages throughout the Ming and Qing.\n They were not necessarily male \u2014 women needed to be able to read to do \nembroidery work. <sup>31<\/sup>\n If this functionally literate population had some spare pocket money, \nthey could have purchased books. They were participants in cultural \nconsumption, and their participation shattered the traditional notion of\n literate cultural consumers as limited to the elite literati and \nscholarly class.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">David Johnson\u2019s study of writing and oral culture in the Ming and \nQing dynasties divides Chinese society into nine socio-cultural groups \nbased on various combinations of education\/literacy and social dominance\n (including economic capacity), at three different levels. The highest \nlevel of education\/literary is comprised of people who received a \nclassical education; beneath this lies an additional literate level, \nfollowed by an illiterate level. The intermediate or functionally \nliterate population cuts across the traditional class boundaries of \nscholars, farmers, laborers, and merchants, as does the population with \nthe economic capacity to share in cultural consumption.<sup>32<\/sup> These are the \u201cfour classes of the people\u201d (<em>simin<\/em> \u56db\u6c11) and the literati and scholars (<em>shimin<\/em> \u58eb\u6c11) the Fujian daily-use encyclopedias mention in their titles and prefaces<sup>33<\/sup> in hopes of attracting the maximum number of literate consumers across all social classes. Chao Yuan, in <em>A Marriage to Awaken the World,<\/em>\n for example, had no particular interest in books, but he nonetheless \nkept them for reference; and he could afford books once his family had \nbecome well-off after his father passed the provincial imperial \nexamination and was appointed a county magistrate. Other potential \npurchasers of Fujian daily-use encyclopedias included medium- and \nsmall-scale urban merchants and workshop owners as well as members of \nthe landed class residing in the countryside.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Thus Fujian daily-use encyclopedias were distinct from more \ntraditional works in appearance, the reading practices they assumed, the\n editing strategies they employed, and the market niche they served. In \nthe late Ming, the lowest classes were barely able to fulfill their \nbasic survival needs and lacked the capacity for cultural consumption; \nthe elite class at the apex of the literate population had no need to \nconsume cheaply priced, crude works like the Fujian daily-use \nencyclopedias. When the need for an encyclopedia arose, they had access \nto better options, including works like <em>Assembled Illustrations of the Three Realms<\/em> and <em>Household Essentials.<\/em>\n At the same time, ordinary people who, though well enough off, lacked \nextensive education, could afford to purchase a variety of books. From \nthe many options available to them, they could easily purchase Fujian \ndaily-use encyclopedias priced at one tael.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Fujian daily-use encyclopedias were a new type of publication that, \nlaying outside the confines of traditional texts of civil service \nexamination study, poetry and literary collections, and orthodox \nencyclopedias, provided access to books to people with a limited level \nof literacy and some degree of economic security. Such people were part \nof society prior to the late Ming, but during the late Ming they emerged\n in great numbers, spurring dramatic changes in the book market and in \ncultural consumption and production. Fujian daily-use encyclopedias \nbecame a new type of consumer good, representing a new way of consuming \nbooks. Consumption of such works was rooted in contemporary social \ntrends outside the bounds of traditional knowledge frameworks and the \nway of reading \u2014 and the way of life \u2014 that assumed that part of one\u2019s \ntime would be devoted to agriculture and part of one\u2019s time to study. \nNew definitions of how one should live and what knowledge was permeated \nsocial spaces and shaped the discourse of the day. Below, I will \ninvestigate more deeply the novel attitudes toward the proper way to \nlive and the understanding of useful knowledge that emerged in the late \nMing by discussing the painting and calligraphy sections of the Fujian \ndaily-use encyclopedias and comparing them to different types of \nartistic consumables. Thus, I hope to attain a fuller understanding of \nthe readers and social spaces of Fujian daily-use encyclopedias, and to \ninvestigate contemporary social differentiation as it was expressed in \nthe consumption of visual products and information on the arts.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<h2 class=\"wp-block-heading\" id=\"art-social-life-and-fashionable-topics-calligraphy-and-painting\">Art, Social life, and Fashionable Topics: Calligraphy and Painting<\/h2>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">\u201cCalligraphy\u201d and \u201cPainting Manual\u201d sections are common components of\n Fujian daily-use encyclopedias of the late Ming. The two sections are \ngenerally linked, with the calligraphy section coming first. The upper \nrow of the \u201cCalligraphy\u201d section generally presents key information on \ncalligraphy and examples of writing styles, with text and pictures in \nequal proportion, while the bottom row consists mainly of illustrations,\n explaining the eight representative strokes and providing samples of \nconventional techniques. The upper row of the \u201cPainting Manual\u201d section \nconsists of hints for appreciating and composing paintings and is made \nup mostly of text, including bits of basic knowledge such as \u201cSecret \nTips for Painting Likenesses.\u201d The lower row is a painting manual \npresenting models of plums and bamboo as well as complete model \npaintings of landscapes, flowers, and birds, occasionally including \nhuman figures and livestock.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Painting and calligraphy sections became standard components of \nFujian daily-use encyclopedias because of the contemporary demand for \ninformation on these topics. Other related sections of the encyclopedias\n also treat painting and calligraphy as part of daily life; there is no \nspecial explanation of their presence in these sections, indicating that\n they had already been accepted as elements of social practice. Model \nletters requesting paintings are found in the \u201cCorrespondence\u201d sections \ndesigned exclusively to teach readers how to write letters.<sup>34<\/sup> And the sections on selecting auspicious days include auspicious days for painting portraits.<sup>35<\/sup>\n Extant paintings from the late Ming onward reflect an interest in the \ndepiction of individuals or groups in society, in portraits of ancestors\n or groups of merrymakers, which often include figures from different \nsocial strata.<sup>36<\/sup>\n \u201cSecret Tips for Painting Likenesses\u201d in the \u201cPainting Manual\u201d section \nof the encyclopedias cites fragments from Wang Yi\u2019s \u738b\u7e79 (1333-?) <em>Secret Tips for Painting Portraits<\/em>\n (Xiexiang mijue \u5beb\u50cf\u79d8\u8a23), the earliest extant work of the theory of \nportraiture. Wang Yi was himself a highly skilled professional portrait \npainter, and his text is highly technical; based on the principles of \nphysiognomy, its instructions on sketching and coloring figures lend an \nair of advanced knowledge to its discussion of portrait-painting \ntechnique.<sup>37<\/sup> The citations from <em>Secret Tips for Painting Portraits<\/em>\n in the encyclopedias, however, are likely not intended to educate \npainters, as portrait painting was a highly specialized technique passed\n down from master to disciple. Rather, the citations show that painting \nportraits had become a common social practice about which literate \nconsumers were expected to know.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Other social customs related to painting are revealed by \nletter-writing instructions in the encyclopedias. Before guests were \ntreated to a banquet, the host would write letters asking to borrow \nhanging scrolls to adorn the banquet hall walls;<sup>38<\/sup> a model response from a friend who was sending some paintings refers to ink wash paintings and four landscape paintings.<sup>39<\/sup>\n Paintings served as a medium of human social interaction, as adornments\n adding to the atmosphere of joyous eating and drinking at banquets, and\n as presents exchanged among friends. This was the case with calligraphy\n as well; samples and practice models played a role in social exchange.<sup>40<\/sup><\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Formerly only available for consumption and enjoyment by the upper \nclasses, painting and calligraphy had thus by the late Ming become \ncultural products that played an important social role in the lives of \nordinary people. As the literate population grew, inevitably a greater \nnumber of people were able to appreciate and create works of calligraphy\n than in earlier periods. Fujian daily-use encyclopedias provide \nexamples of antithetical couplets (<em>duilian<\/em> \u5c0d\u806f) for a wide range of occasions and professions; as a form for the display of calligraphy, antithetical couplets, which were <em>de rigueur<\/em>\n means of honoring major life events (weddings, official postings, shop \nopenings, holidays, etc.) spread far and wide. As for painting, works \nwith multiple functions began appearing in large numbers in the mid-Ming\n dynasty, serving as objects of gift exchange in a wide range of social \noccasions, to commemorate birthdays, weddings, and retirements or to be \ndisplayed during celebrations such as the New Year and the Dragon Boat \nFestival.<sup>41<\/sup>\n Studies have shown that, by the mid-Ming, celebrating birthdays had \nbecome a widespread social custom. Among young and old alike, and across\n all social strata, it was common to give paintings and calligraphy as \ngifts on these occasions. Liu Ruoyu\u2019s \u5289\u82e5\u611a (1584-ca. 1642) account of his\n life as a eunuch in the imperial palace in the late sixteenth and early\n seventeenth centuries, tells us that images of Tian Guan \u5929\u5b98 and Zhong \nKui \u937e\u9997 were hung on New Year\u2019s Day, and pictures of priests and \nimmortals were used in an attempt to drive out the five poisonous \ncreatures during the Dragon Boat Festival. <sup>42<\/sup> In addition, the \u201cHanging Paintings, Month by Month\u201d chapter of Wen Zhenheng\u2019s <em>Treatise on Superfluous Things<\/em> (<em>Zhang wu zhi<\/em>\n \u9577\u7269\u5fd7), which explains which paintings were appropriate to hang for each \nseason and occasion, states that portraits of Tian Guan and the ancient \nsages were for the New Year and images of Zhong Kui, mugwort,<sup>43<\/sup> the five poisonous creatures, etc., for the Dragon Boat Festival.<sup>44<\/sup>\n To be sure, Liu Ruoyu was describing the customs of the imperial court;\n and most of the paintings Wen Zhenheng recommends hanging (he suggests \nthat they should be changed more than ten times a year) were famous \nworks of the Song and Yuan that ordinary families could not have \nafforded. But the customs mentioned by the two authors cut across social\n classes. The paintings selected by different classes would have similar\n themes, although their size and degree of renown would depend upon \nindividual financial resources and social connections.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Since paintings and calligraphy deeply permeated social life, it is \nunlikely that they were difficult to buy or sell, although of course \npurchasing the work of famous artists was not easy, necessitating \npersonal introductions and expenditure of much money and time.<sup>45<\/sup>\n Fujian daily-use encyclopedias include a letter format that perhaps \nreflects a state of affairs that was common at the time: the letter \nrequests that the recipient purchase regular script calligraphy practice\n models for the sender when visiting a nearby city. The letter does not \nspecify the name of a specific shop or seller, indicating that \ntransactions in painting- and calligraphy-related goods were commonplace\n in cities.<sup>46<\/sup>\n The scholar-official and art connoisseur Li Rihua \u674e\u65e5\u83ef (1565-1635) \nwrites that, during his term as an official in Beijing during the late \nsixteenth and early seventeenth century, long handscrolls such as Along \nthe River during the Qingming <em>Festival<\/em> (<em>Qingming shang he tu<\/em> \u6e05\u660e\u4e0a\u6cb3\u5716)<sup>47<\/sup> could be purchased easily at general stores in the capital at the price of one tael.<sup>48<\/sup>\n Indeed, we know that by the Northern Song dynasty at the latest, \npaintings and works of calligraphy commonly changed hands at periodic \ncity markets and shops.<sup>49<\/sup>\n What were the unique characteristics of such transactions in the late \nMing? From Li Rihua we learn that paintings and works of calligraphy \nwere bought and sold even more commonly in the late Ming, not only in \nthe capital but in the cities of Jiangnan, and not only at regularly \nscheduled markets but at shops and streetside stalls. Such transactions \ntook place not just at specialist art stores, but even at general goods \nstores.<sup>50<\/sup>\n In seventeenth and eighteenth century illustrations of urban life, \nshops and stalls selling paintings, calligraphy, and antiques often \nappear as part of the urban landscape, in contrast to Zhang Zeduan\u2019s \u5f35\u64c7\u7aef\n <em>Along the River during the Qingming Festival,<\/em> a late Northern Song handscroll that, in its urban market scenes, depicts no transactions in paintings or calligraphy.<sup>51<\/sup>\n To be sure, illustrations do not necessarily reflect reality, but it is\n apparent that the circulation of cultural products such as paintings \nand calligraphy was part of the image of urban life in the late-Ming \ndynasty, and the ability to consume paintings and calligraphy easily and\n quickly was a distinguishing feature of contemporary urban culture as \nwell as a component of \u201curbanity.\u201d<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Thus paintings and calligraphy played important roles in the social networks and relationships in the late Ming. But toward <em>what<\/em>\n kinds of lifestyles are the specialized \u201cCalligraphy\u201d and \u201cPainting \nManual\u201d sections of the Fujian daily-use encyclopedias oriented?<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">A comparison of the \u201cCalligraphy\u201d sections of the different types of \ndaily-use encyclopedias helps answer this question. Although <em>Expansive Record of the Forest of Literati<\/em>\n does not include a separate calligraphy section, it does provide sample\n calligraphic scripts in its \u201cLiterature and Arts\u201d section. There we \nfind models of cursive script (<em>cao shu<\/em> \u8349\u66f8), seal script (<em>seal script<\/em> \u7bc6\u66f8), clerical script (<em>li shu<\/em>\n \u540f\u66f8), and Mongolian script. At most about seven hundred characters are \nlisted, with their meaning and pronunciation. Instruction is provided in\n identifying and writing in scripts other than the regular script (<em>kai shu<\/em>\n \u6977\u66f8); the section on cursive script in particular is of a highly \npractical nature, even including a series of instructions in rhyme. <sup>52<\/sup> The inclusion of Mongolian script shows that the Fujian publishers had adapted their works to changing geopolitical realities.<sup>53<\/sup> The model scripts of <em>Expansive Record<\/em> could conceivably serve, like a character dictionary, to instruct a learner in reading and writing characters.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">In contrast, the late-Ming daily-use encyclopedias seem to fulfill a \ndifferent purpose. Although also explaining cursive and clerical \nscripts, they pay special attention to seal script, including up to \neighteen different varieties of the script and giving a minimum of five \nand a maximum of fifty sample characters for each variety. Seal script, \nthe most ancient of the Chinese scripts, was used in a variety of \ndifferent forms prior to the unification of China under the Qin dynasty \nin 221 BCE, when the state created a uniform script designed to replace \nthe many kinds of scripts in use at the time. Perhaps because of its \nantiquity, seal script was regarded as the highest form of calligraphy, \nbut by the late Ming it was obsolete. The unusual \u2014 we might say \n\u201cstrange\u201d \u2014 forms of this archaic script appealed greatly to late-Ming \nreaders. Scholars of calligraphy attest that there was a vogue for seal \nscript in the late Ming and that the fashion influenced contemporary \ncalligraphic styles.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">But the Fujian late-Ming daily-use encyclopedias extravagantly \u2014 and \ninaccurately \u2014exaggerate the \u201cstrangeness\u201d of seal script. The Deep \nOcean of Myriad Books, for example, provides seal script renderings of \ntwo series of characters, \u874c\u86aa\u9853\u980a\u4f5c and \u6696\u6c5f\u9326\u9c57\u805a (reproduced here in regular \nscript), that are meaningless as phrases. In the encyclopedia\u2019s seal \nscript versions, each stroke in each character of the first phrase is \nmade up of tadpole-like dots connected to a long line \u2014and, certainly \nnot coincidentally, the first two characters mean \u201ctadpole\u201d (Figure 4); \nand each character in the second phrase \u2014 which includes the word for \n\u201cfish scales\u201d \u2014 is made up of a school of fish (Figure 5), giving \ngreater priority to visual impact than meaning.<sup>54<\/sup>\n These examples, bearing no relationship to real seal script, reflect a \nplayful fascination with both striking visual effects and \u201cstrange\u201d \nwriting forms that was typical of the late Ming.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<figure class=\"wp-block-image\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" width=\"379\" height=\"625\" src=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image5.png\" alt=\"\" class=\"wp-image-187\" srcset=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image5.png 379w, https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image5-182x300.png 182w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 379px) 100vw, 379px\" \/><\/figure>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Figure 4: From the \u201cCalligraphy\u201d section of <em>Deep Ocean of Myriad Books,<\/em> in <em>Ch\u016bgoku nichiy\u014d ruisho sh\u016bsei,<\/em> 6: 436.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<figure class=\"wp-block-image\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" width=\"394\" height=\"672\" src=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image6.png\" alt=\"\" class=\"wp-image-188\" srcset=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image6.png 394w, https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image6-176x300.png 176w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 394px) 100vw, 394px\" \/><\/figure>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Figure 5: From the \u201cCalligraphy\u201d section of <em>Deep Ocean of Myriad Books,<\/em> in <em>Ch\u016bgoku nichiy\u014d ruisho sh\u016bsei,<\/em> 6: 441.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Both the literature and art of the period express a thirst for \nnovelty that, in the popular books in vogue at the time, manifested \nitself in pursuit of unusual pictorial effects as well as widespread use\n of rare characters and variant character forms. In this context, in \nwhich the competition to discover or create the latest curiosity was \nintense, seal script was the perfect means by which to satisfy the \ndemand for whimsy and the strange. Literati used unusual characters in \ndrinking games; and phrases in odd styles of calligraphy were often \npresented as visual conundrums to be solved at poetry parties.<sup>55<\/sup>\n Phrases such as the above-described \u6696\u6c5f\u9326\u9c57\u805a served as visual riddles \nwhich, while lacking intellectual depth, were nonetheless entertaining. \nThere were authoritative reference works on such characters, including \ncontemporary character dictionaries such as <em>Unusual Characters in Ancient Prose<\/em> (<em>Guwen qizi<\/em> \u53e4\u6587\u5947\u5b57) and <em>Notes on the Explication of Written Characters<\/em> (<em>Shuowen changjian<\/em> \u8aaa\u6587\u9577\u7b8b).<sup>56<\/sup>\n However, the made-up characters \u2014 the tadpole and fish characters \u2014 of \nthe Fujian daily-use encyclopedias were not based on these authoritative\n sources, but were created for visual effect to conform to contemporary \npopular taste. Moreover, unlike the earlier <em>Expansive Record from the Forest of Literati,<\/em>\n these late-Ming encyclopedias, in providing only small extracts of many\n different varieties of seal script, are of no use to a reader who \nwished to learn calligraphy.<sup>57<\/sup><\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Indeed, it is apparent that the \u201cCalligraphy\u201d sections of the \nlate-Ming Fujian daily-use encyclopedias were not created specifically \nfor purposes of educating readers about calligraphy. A comparison of the\n information on calligraphy in several different daily-use encyclopedias\n confirms this assessment. One entry seems to have been common to almost\n all these works: that titled the \u201c<em>Yong<\/em> Character Eight Strokes\n Method.\u201d This method was a system for the study of calligraphy that \ntaught the eight basic types of strokes that can be used to write most \nChinese characters. As all eight of these strokes are contained in the \ncharacter <em>yong<\/em> (\u6c38), the method was named <em>yongzi bafa<\/em>, literally \u201c<em>yong<\/em>\n character eight stroke method.\u201d The origins of the method are unknown, \nalthough scholars over the centuries have attributed it to calligraphers\n of the Han, Six Dynasties, and Tang periods. <sup>58<\/sup><\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">The Yuan dynasty daily-use encyclopedia <em>Complete Collection of Essential Household Knowledge<\/em> incorporates the method into its section on writing characters, retitling it \u201cThe <em>Yong<\/em>\n Character Eight Strokes Method of the Gods\u201d, recounting a legend that \nEastern Han dynasty calligrapher Cai Yong \u8521\u9095 (133-192) received the \neight-stroke method from divine agents while visiting a cave on Mt. \nSong. An entry entitled \u201cLi Yangbing\u2019s \u674e\u967d\u51b0 Calligraphy Tips,\u201d named \nafter a famous Tang-dynasty calligrapher, offers tips on the eight types\n of strokes.<sup>59<\/sup> The later <em>Household Essentials<\/em> reproduces this whole section exactly as it appears in <em>Complete Collection of Essential Household Knowledge<\/em>.<sup>60<\/sup><\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\"><em>Assembled Illustrations of the Three Realms,<\/em> the encyclopedia produced for elite literati readers, opens its fascicles on calligraphy with \u201c<em>Yong<\/em>\n Character Eight Stokes Method\u201d, and then provides tips on reading and \nwriting cursive, clerical, and seal scripts. It provides so many sample \ncharacters \u2014 over one thousand \u2014 that this section could function as a \nsmall-scale character dictionary. Students are told to copy the style of\n the famous calligrapher Yan Zhenqing \u984f\u771f\u537f (709-785) when practicing \nlarge block script. Yan\u2019s style, characterized by coarse black strokes \nproduced by pressing outward on the brush with the thumb, was \ncustomarily recommended as a model in late-Ming instructional manuals; \ncalligrapher Feng Fang\u2019s \u8c50\u4eff (1493-1566) <em>Calligraphy Curriculum for Children<\/em>\n (Tongxue shucheng \u7ae5\u5b78\u66f8\u7a0b) states that eight-year-old children learning \nthe basics of calligraphy should copy Yan Zhenqing\u2019s block script from \nrubbings of several of his most famous stele inscriptions.<sup>61<\/sup> All these inscriptions are listed as models in <em>Assembled Illustrations.<\/em><sup>62<\/sup><\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Some Fujian daily-use encyclopedias, such as <em>Deep Ocean of Myriad Books<\/em> and <em>Five Carts of Select Marvels<\/em>, also discuss the \u201c<em>yong<\/em>\n character eight stroke method\u201d and even the divinely bestowed eight \nstroke method of Cai Yong. The contents of their calligraphy sections \u2014 \nin the illustrations to the <em>yong<\/em> character method and in \u201cIllustrations of Seventy-two Calligraphic Variations\u201d \u2014 overlap with those of <em>Assembled Illustrations of the Three Realms,<\/em><sup>63<\/sup>\n but differences in the details of their instructions eliminates the \npossibility of direct copying. The samples of regular script in <em>Deep Ocean of Myriad Books<\/em> and <em>Five Carts of Select Marvels<\/em>\n include approximately forty characters, the most of any encyclopedia of\n this type, but far fewer than the number of characters in <em>Assembled Illustrations of the Three Realms<\/em>. The characters are written in the style of Yan Zhenqing, as in the latter work, but in <em>Deep Ocean<\/em> they were accompanied by rhymed instructions printed in the margins (Figure 6).<\/p>\n\n\n\n<figure class=\"wp-block-image\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" width=\"464\" height=\"794\" src=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image7.png\" alt=\"\" class=\"wp-image-189\" srcset=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image7.png 464w, https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image7-175x300.png 175w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 464px) 100vw, 464px\" \/><\/figure>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Figure 6: \u201cModel of Regular Style Calligraphy\u201d from the \u201cCalligraphy\u201d section of <em>Deep Ocean of Myriad Books,<\/em> in <em>Ch\u016bgoku nichiy\u014d ruisho sh\u016bsei,<\/em> 6: 453.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\"><em>Deep Ocean of Myriad Books<\/em> is the Fujian daily-use \nencyclopedia with the highest number of illustrations of calligraphic \nstyles; it did provide students with some models of regular script and \nthus could be used as a reference for beginners. But most other \nlate-Ming Fujian encyclopedias, including only perfunctory illustrations\n of the eight stroke method \u2014 and omitting entirely any explanation of \nthe seventy-two calligraphic styles &#8212; were of limited practical use. \nOne does not learn calligraphy by studying ten characters here and there\n \u2014 and these encyclopedias often provided at the most only ten sample \ncharacters.<sup>64<\/sup>\n During this period, dedicated calligraphy manuals provided plentiful \nmodels and inscription rubbings to copy; and their prefaces made clear \nthat they were to be purchased for calligraphy study, not entertainment.<sup>65<\/sup>\n The calligraphy sections of the late-Ming Fujian encyclopedias, in \ncontrast, were designed to provide prompts for conversation for those \nwishing to appear knowledgeable about calligraphy rather than helpful \ninstruction in the art itself.<sup>66<\/sup><\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Although they were not useful instructional texts, these \nencyclopedias did adapt to contemporary trends in calligraphy through \ntheir focus on seal script, their adherence to the Yan Zhenqing style as\n a model, and in their references to the <em>yong<\/em> character eight \nstroke method. They also presented basic information on the evaluation \nof calligraphy in the form of brief appraisals appearing alongside their\n models. In the social world of the late Ming, it was important not only\n to be able to write well, but also to be able to evaluate the \ncalligraphy of others intelligently. Social gatherings were frequent, \nand associations and clubs devoted to the arts were in vogue. Dedicated \ninstructional texts and literacy manuals were directed to the individual\n reader-student, but in this period the individual was often pressed to \nstudy \u2014 or to display the fruits of his or her study \u2014 in the presence \nof others. Calligraphy became a means of showing off individual skill in\n social contexts; such skill (or lack thereof) could determine one\u2019s \nprestige and position in society. Particularly because the late Ming was\n a time of shifting identities and ambiguous class distinctions, an \nindividual\u2019s external appearance, social skills, and demonstration of \ntalent \u2014 or ability to recognize and appreciate talent &#8212; to some extent\n determined his or her social identity.<sup>67<\/sup>\n If the instructions on calligraphy in the late-Ming Fujian daily-use \nencyclopedias were of little practical help to students, they could at \nleast suggest ways in which their intended readers \u2014 people with some \neducation, but not enough to place them in the class of the elite \u2014 \nmight talk about calligraphy.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">The \u201cPainting Manual\u201d sections of the daily life encyclopedias, like \nthose on calligraphy, reflect contemporary artistic trends and the \nincreased social role of painting in the Ming. Dedicated painting \nmanuals, very popular from the mid-Ming on, often presented models for \nthe painting of a wide range of subjects, including plums, bamboo, \norchids, chrysanthemums, animals, birds, and people. By the late Ming, \nthese manuals came to focus on landscapes, flowers, and birds (Figures \n15, 16), devoting very little attention to either portraiture or \narchitectural painting, both of which required advanced technical \nproficiency. In this they were reflecting the tastes of the day: \nlate-Ming artists and connoisseurs embraced the styles and aesthetics of\n Yuan dynasty \u201cliterati\u201d (<em>wenren<\/em> \u6587\u4eba) painters,<sup>68<\/sup>\n who emphasized interesting ink work, not skilled technique. As a \nresult, literati-style ink landscape paintings prevailed to such an \nextent that paintings of structurally, compositionally proficient \nportrait painting and architectural painting were looked down upon. This\n mainstream view is often seen in contemporary treatises on literati \npainting and, though challenged by Fujian literati such as Xie Zhaozhe \n\u8b1d\u8087\u6ddb (1567-1624), the trend was so prevalent that even the daily-use \nencyclopedias of the regional Fujian publishers bowed to it.<sup>69<\/sup><\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Encyclopedias like <em>Assembled Illustrations of the Three Realms<\/em>\n treated the whole range of subjects popular in the late Ming. It also \nquotes several painting manuals compiled by Zhou L\u00fcjing \u5468\u5c65\u9756 (1542-1633) \nin the late sixteenth and early seventeenth century, including his \nguides to the drawing of plums, orchids, and birds.<sup>70<\/sup>\n In contrast, few Fujian daily-use encyclopedias contain multiple \nmanuals for a range of subjects. Some feature full-scale woodcut \nillustrations of landscapes, flowers, and birds, while just two \nillustrations depict livestock; and depictions of human figures and \narchitecture, following the fashion of the day, are few. They usually \ninclude instruction only on plums and bamboo, the most common models in \nall manuals,<sup>71<\/sup> with far fewer model pictures even of these subjects (see Figures 7 and 8).<sup>72<\/sup><\/p>\n\n\n\n<figure class=\"wp-block-image\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" width=\"353\" height=\"576\" src=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image8.png\" alt=\"\" class=\"wp-image-190\" srcset=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image8.png 353w, https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image8-184x300.png 184w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 353px) 100vw, 353px\" \/><\/figure>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Figure 7: \u201cPlum Model\u201d from the \u201cPainting Manual\u201d section of <em>Deep Ocean of Myriad Books,<\/em> in <em>Ch\u016bgoku nichiy\u014d ruisho sh\u016bsei,<\/em> 7: 24.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<figure class=\"wp-block-image\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" width=\"361\" height=\"575\" src=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image9.png\" alt=\"\" class=\"wp-image-191\" srcset=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image9.png 361w, https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image9-188x300.png 188w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 361px) 100vw, 361px\" \/><\/figure>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Figure 8: \u201cBamboo Model from the \u201cPainting Manual\u201d section of <em>Deep Ocean of Myriad Books,<\/em> in <em>Ch\u016bgoku nichiy\u014d ruisho sh\u016bsei,<\/em> 7: 32.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">The few isolated illustrations of plums and bamboo and the scant \nrhymed instructions that accompany them in these texts could not serve \nto cultivate true painters. Even <em>Five Carts of Select Marvels<\/em>, \nwhich contains the greatest number of illustrations of plums, includes \nno more than thirty-some models; moreover, its low-grade calligraphy \nmake it unsuitable for instruction (Figures 9, 10).<sup>73<\/sup>\n The models of plums and bamboo in Fujian daily-use encyclopedias \u2014 \nalong with the occasional woodcut illustrations of landscapes, flowers, \nand birds and the almost complete absence of portraits and architectural\n models \u2014 did, however, provide the reader with hints of recent trends \nin painting, granting the reader some slight sense of participation in \nthe contemporary art world.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<figure class=\"wp-block-image\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" width=\"444\" height=\"752\" src=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image10.png\" alt=\"\" class=\"wp-image-192\" srcset=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image10.png 444w, https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image10-177x300.png 177w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 444px) 100vw, 444px\" \/><\/figure>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Figure 9: \u201cLandscape Painting Model\u201d from the \u201cPainting Manual\u201d section of <em>Deep Ocean of Myriad Books,<\/em> in <em>Ch\u016bgoku nichiy\u014d ruisho sh\u016bsei,<\/em> 7: 24.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<figure class=\"wp-block-image\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" width=\"456\" height=\"745\" src=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image11.png\" alt=\"\" class=\"wp-image-193\" srcset=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image11.png 456w, https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image11-184x300.png 184w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 456px) 100vw, 456px\" \/><\/figure>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Figure 10: \u201cFlower and Bird Painting Model\u201d from the \u201cPainting Manual\u201d section of <em>Deep Ocean of Myriad Books,<\/em> in <em>Ch\u016bgoku nichiy\u014d ruisho sh\u016bsei,<\/em> 7: 24.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">In their (limited) value as a source of information about painting \u2014 \nas opposed to instruction about how to paint \u2014 the Fujian daily-life \nencyclopedias bear comparison with another kind of painting manual \npopular in the late Ming. These were manuals whose purpose was to \nprovide some degree of information about the history of Chinese \npainting. Examples include <em>Gu\u2019s Painting Manual (Gu Shi huapu<\/em> \u9867\u6c0f\u756b\u8b5c) and <em>Tang Poetry Painting Manual (Tang shi huapu<\/em>\n \u5510\u8a69\u756b\u8b5c). The former, edited by Gu Bing \u9867\u70b3, claims to provide pictures of \npaintings by famous artists; each picture is accompanied by a biography \nof that artist. The volume includes 106 pictures, including work by Six \nDynasties artist Gu Kaizhi \u9867\u6137\u4e4b (ca. 344-406), Tang dynasty artist Yan \nLiben \u95bb\u7acb\u672c (600-673), and mid-Ming dynasty artists Wen Zhengming \u6587\u5fb5\u660e \n(1470-1559) and Lin Liang \u6797\u826f (ca. 1424-1500). Even the work of \ncontemporary artist Dong Qichang \u8463\u5176\u660c (1555-1636) is exhaustively treated\n (See Figures 11 and 12). The biographies following the pictures are \nattributed to contemporary celebrities like Qi Chenghan \u7941\u627f\u3e01 (1565-1628),\n to whom is credited the biography of the even greater celebrity Dong \nQichang<sup>74<\/sup>I\n will address later on the problems associated with the accuracy of the \nrepresentations of artistic styles in this work; here the point is that \nthe publication of books such as this in the late Ming shows that there \nwas a demand for information about painting as well as a need for actual\n paintings to appreciate and enjoy. For those who could not afford \nscroll paintings, as well as those with the means to purchase them but \nnot the knowledge to appreciate them, <em>Gu\u2019s Painting Manual<\/em> offered help: a handy digest of high-class cultural products.<sup>75<\/sup>\n Thanks to his pictures, which claimed to represent the work of such \nartistic greats as Gu Kaizhi and Dong Qichang, elite lifestyles seemed \nto be within reach.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<figure class=\"wp-block-image\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" width=\"413\" height=\"591\" src=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image12.png\" alt=\"\" class=\"wp-image-194\" srcset=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image12.png 413w, https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image12-210x300.png 210w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 413px) 100vw, 413px\" \/><\/figure>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Figure 11: \u201cModel of Eagles by Lin Liang\u201d in <em>Gu\u2019s Painting Manual<\/em>. Peking University Library Collection.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<figure class=\"wp-block-image\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" width=\"431\" height=\"585\" src=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image13-2.png\" alt=\"\" class=\"wp-image-197\" srcset=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image13-2.png 431w, https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image13-2-221x300.png 221w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 431px) 100vw, 431px\" \/><\/figure>\n\n\n\n<figure class=\"wp-block-image\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" width=\"440\" height=\"636\" src=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image14.png\" alt=\"\" class=\"wp-image-198\" srcset=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image14.png 440w, https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image14-208x300.png 208w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 440px) 100vw, 440px\" \/><\/figure>\n\n\n\n<figure class=\"wp-block-image\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" width=\"431\" height=\"585\" src=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image13-1.png\" alt=\"\" class=\"wp-image-196\" srcset=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image13-1.png 431w, https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image13-1-221x300.png 221w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 431px) 100vw, 431px\" \/><\/figure>\n\n\n\n<figure class=\"wp-block-image\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" width=\"431\" height=\"585\" src=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image13.png\" alt=\"\" class=\"wp-image-195\" srcset=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image13.png 431w, https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image13-221x300.png 221w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 431px) 100vw, 431px\" \/><\/figure>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Figure 12: \u201cModel of Painting by Dong Qichang\u201d in <em>Gu\u2019s Painting Manual.<\/em> Peking University Library Collection.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">The <em>Tang Poetry Painting Manual,<\/em> by visually interpreting \nfamous lines of poetry, attempts to achieve the ultimate embodiment of \nthe \u201cunity of painting and poetry\u201d celebrated in theories of painting by\n artists and scholars throughout the ages. Tang poetry was popular in \nthe late-Ming dynasty, and lines with clear narrative qualities and \ndistinct imagery were chosen for inclusion in painting manuals.<sup>76<\/sup>\n In this particular work, the figures in the paintings are clearly posed\n so as to illustrate the plot details of the poems, while the landscape \nportions emphasize a range of brush techniques of famous painters, \nincluding Ma Yuan\u2019s \u99ac\u9060 (1160-1225) \u201cax hacking strokes,\u201d the Mi \n\u7c73-family\u2019s \u201craindrop strokes\u201d (Figure 13), and Wang Meng\u2019s \u738b\u8499 (ca. \n1308-1385) \u201cox hair strokes\u201d (Figure 14), as well as skillful use of ink\n and water.<sup>77<\/sup><\/p>\n\n\n\n<figure class=\"wp-block-image\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" width=\"440\" height=\"636\" src=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image14-1.png\" alt=\"\" class=\"wp-image-203\" srcset=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image14-1.png 440w, https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image14-1-208x300.png 208w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 440px) 100vw, 440px\" \/><\/figure>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Figure 13: \u201cLandscape in the Style of the Mi Family\u201d from Huang Fengchi, <em>Tang Poetry Painting Manual,<\/em> in <em>Zhongguo gudai banshu congkan er bian<\/em>, 265, held by the Shanghai Library, Peking University Library, and East China Normal University Library.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<figure class=\"wp-block-image\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" width=\"439\" height=\"618\" src=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image15-1.png\" alt=\"\" class=\"wp-image-202\" srcset=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image15-1.png 439w, https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image15-1-213x300.png 213w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 439px) 100vw, 439px\" \/><\/figure>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Figure 14: \u201cLandscape in the Style of Wang Meng\u201d from Huang Fengchi, <em>Tang Poetry Painting Manual,<\/em> in <em>Zhongguo gudai banshu congkan er bian<\/em>, 265, held by the Shanghai Library, Peking University Library, and East China Normal University Library.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">It was no simple matter for woodblock illustrations to depict each \nstroke and ink blot of paintings, and that this painting manual \nnonetheless made the attempt indicates the degree to which the fashion \nin late-Ming painting circles was to value ink work above all else. The <em>Tang Poetry Painting Manual<\/em>\n conformed to prevailing tendencies in both poetry and painting, \nattempting to imbue the text with an elite cultural ambiance not \nnormally accessible to its readers, as well as to provide paintings for \nthem to appreciate and enjoy.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Fujian daily-use encyclopedias also follow these trends, as is \nevident in their inclusion of painting manuals alone. There is a high \ndegree of overlap among the paintings depicted in different editions; \nand the paintings selected are quite similar across the encyclopedias.<sup>78<\/sup>\n In terms of quality, the woodblock prints in the encyclopedias are far \nmore modest than those in the two above-mentioned painting manuals; they\n do not even come close to capturing mainstream painting styles. Only \ntwo of the illustrations of brush technique bear any resemblance to real\n paintings, a Mi family-style ink dot landscape (Figure 15) \u2014 the ink \ndot style was relatively easy to represent \u2014 and a picture of flowers, \nbirds, and branches. In spite of their crudeness, such illustrations \nwere selected for inclusion in daily-use encyclopedias because it was \nnecessary for the works to keep up with contemporary trends in order to \nattract readers.<sup>79<\/sup><\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Previously, scholars have emphasized the practical nature and \ninstructional functions of Fujian daily-use encyclopedias. It is \npossible that certain sections may have helped readers resolve practical\n problems or learn basic skills but, based on the above discussion, it \nis apparent that these works were ultimately concerned with topicality \nand popularity; their functions differed from those of other types and \neditions of daily-use encyclopedias, either those intended for the rural\n gentry or those designed for sophisticated literati and scholars. From \nthis discussion of the painting and calligraphy sections in particular, \nit should be clear that Fujian daily-use encyclopedias, in choosing to \npresent up-to-date information on social trends, greatly limited their \npotential as guides to practical action or to the education of children.\n The lifestyles promoted in the encyclopedias did not center on the \neveryday pursuit of basic necessities or household management, as has \nbeen surmised but were, rather, preoccupied with social performance \u2014 \nthe techniques of successful social interaction and the ability to know \nwhat was fashionable and topical \u201cnow.\u201d A \u201cprofligate entertainment \nculture\u201d (<em>zidi wenhua<\/em> \u5b50\u5f1f\u6587\u5316<sup>80<\/sup>),\n closely bound to urban culture, and both pushing against the bounds of \northodoxy and chafing at the limits imposed by conventional norms and \nrules, had already become mainstream in the late Ming. If this had not \nbeen the case, the Fujian booksellers, motivated by profit and thus \nsensitive to current trends, would not have all produced such similar \npublications, all designed to appeal to an entertainment culture. Fujian\n daily-use encyclopedias of the late Ming existed within an enormous, \ndense network of human relations; and they engage with worldly life and \nsocial spectacle, not with scholarly pursuits or the practical daily \nlife concerns of the gentry.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<h2 class=\"wp-block-heading\" id=\"information-on-the-arts-social-divisions-and-alternative-social-spaces-the-calligraphy-and-painting-manual-sections-of-the-fujian-daily-use-encyclopedias\">Information\n on the Arts, Social Divisions, and Alternative Social Spaces: The \n\u201cCalligraphy\u201d and \u201cPainting Manual\u201d Sections of the Fujian Daily-use \nEncyclopedias<\/h2>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">In their reflection of contemporary lifestyle concerns, the Fujian \ndaily-use encyclopedias are manifestations of social trends and common \ntendencies cutting across the division between the middle and upper \nclasses in late-Ming China. The illiterate population and those scraping\n for basic survival needs obviously lacked the power to pursue these \ntrends, but all those who were literate and capable of consuming books \ncould hope to participate in them thanks to the Fujian daily-use \nencyclopedias which purported to play the role of socioeconomic \nequalizer. But books of this type not only manifested sociocultural \ncommonalities, but also social class divisions: when all people who are \ncapable of doing so immerse themselves in prevailing trends, the \npositions of different classes become even clearer, especially when it \ncomes to possession of cultural capital such as knowledge of painting \nand calligraphy. Those with the ability to appreciate mainstream \nartistic ideas could obtain cultural capital by investing large sums of \nmoney, in addition to relying upon their family background and \neducation. But functionally literate people who lacked significant \namounts of capital had difficulty finding an entry point to the \nenjoyment of and participation in mainstream culture. The Fujian \ndaily-use encyclopedias stepped in to help them.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">We have already seen, in the previous section, that the Fujian \ndaily-use encyclopedias sought to keep up with contemporary trends and \nconform to mainstream social expectations. Yet, in terms of the \nformation and circulation of knowledge, the contents of these books not \nonly reflect contemporary social trends, but also prescribe cultural \nknowledge \u2014 that is, they take part in the creation of late-Ming society\n and culture. The encyclopedias played an active role in constructing \nculture through the information they conveyed. When we compare and \ncontrast the information on painting and calligraphy in these books with\n those of other publications, it becomes clear that the information \ndiffers significantly \u2014 and is even at times conflicting \u2014 across \npublications. It seems that different types of information about the \narts circulated among different groups of people. In these different \ntypes of information we glimpse the vague outlines of different social \nspaces which, while not rigidly demarcated, nonetheless have discernible\n contours. The definition of these different social spaces is the focus \nof this section.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">In the late Ming, information on the arts circulated and artistic \ndiscourse took shape through two channels. The social clubs that were in\n vogue among literati are the first; through these personal networks, \ndiscourse related to the arts was formed through either consensus or \ndebate. The commercialization of knowledge, a process closely bound up \nwith publishing culture, is the second channel. Presumably, these two \nchannels interacted, overlapped, and interlocked extensively, so that \nthey are difficult to separate; they jointly formed a shared marketplace\n of artistic ideas in the late Ming.<sup>81<\/sup>\n Two examples illustrate how these channels might interact. Dong Qichang\n originally expressed his ideas about painting and calligraphy in the \nform of brief annotations on painting and calligraphy scrolls written at\n gatherings of friends and circulated through literary circles by means \nof oral discussion. Dong then later wrote and published (twice in his \nlifetime) On Painting (Hua zhi \u756b\u65e8), which commercialized his artistic \nknowledge by giving readers \u2014 for a price \u2014 the information they needed \nto express opinions on painting at social gatherings.<sup>82<\/sup> Popular in the late Ming, too, were works on lifestyle aesthetics and taste like <em>Treatise on Superfluous Things<\/em> and <em>Eight Treatises on the Nurturing of Life,<\/em>\n which purported to reveal to the public the various articles and \nornaments that marked the material lives of literati \u2014 and to offer \nlifestyle guidance to readers.<sup>83<\/sup> Judging by Shen Chunze\u2019s \u6c88\u6625\u6fa4 preface to <em>Superfluous Things<\/em>, the opinions expressed by the book do to some extent reflect the consensus of taste in literati social circles.<sup>84<\/sup><\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">It is difficult to determine the degree to which the compilers of the\n Fujian daily-use encyclopedias relied on the first channel \u2014 personal \nnetworks and oral transmission \u2014 for their information about mainstream \nculture. The commercialized nature of the information presented in the \nbooks is very clear, however. By extracting and rearranging content from\n other books, such encyclopedias became cultural products providing \ninstruction in the latest trends. Readers could use them to take part in\n conversations at social gatherings, entertain one another, and surround\n themselves with an air of urbanity. This was not traditional \ninformation on science, statecraft, or scholarly knowledge controlled by\n the imperial court or officialdom, but common knowledge integrated \nseamlessly into social life. Commercialized knowledge, gained through \nthe transactions of buying and selling, gradually shaped the social \nnorms of the masses, touched off new trends, and enabled crossover \nbetween social classes. At the same time, because different information \ncirculated among different groups, it also shaped unique social spaces \nthat, while remaining distinct, were occasionally in dialogue with one \nanother.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">The <em>Treatise on Superfluous Things<\/em> advertises the elegance \nand taste of the lifestyles of the literati. To distance themselves from\n the newly rich, who lacked culture in spite of their affluence, this \nand other late-Ming publications set forth a distinction between \n\u201cconnoisseurs\u201d (<em>shangjianjia<\/em> \u8cde\u9452\u5bb6) and \u201cthe curious\u201d (<em>haoshijia<\/em> \u597d\u4e8b\u5bb6).<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">According to <em>Superfluous Things<\/em>, connoisseurs collect, \nintellectually appreciate, and enjoy works of art, as well as know how \nto display and arrange them. On the other hand, the curious merely \ncollect works of art, without the education to appreciate them. As a \nresult, in displaying them, they place forgeries side by side with \ngenuine works and new works alongside old.<sup>85<\/sup> But of course once the tastes and aesthetic practices of the literati, championed by such publications as <em>Superfluous Things<\/em>,\n were for sale on the marketplace, \u201cthe curious\u201d could not be prevented \nfrom imitating them, and they became shared trends. Thus, scholars hold \nthat in the late-Ming dynasty, the boundary between the refined (<em>ya<\/em> \u96c5) and the common (<em>su<\/em>\n \u4fd7) was fluid. Of course, for that very reason, it frequently became \nnecessary to uphold boundaries, and a dialectical opposition developed \nbetween refined and common, high and low tastes, each exerting a pull \nover the other.<sup>86<\/sup><\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\"><em>Superfluous Things<\/em> author Wen Zhenheng forcefully defended \nthe distinction between refined and common out of a concern that the \nmerely curious had overstepped their bounds, blurring traditional \nidentity distinctions and making it impossible to tell real from fake. \nHe expends much effort distinguishing between refined and common because\n the <em>nouveaux riches<\/em>, newly prosperous as a result of the \neconomic changes of the late Ming, were capable of obtaining a quality \nof life originally restricted only to connoisseurs; the two groups now \nhad similar identities on the social pyramid, and it was frequently \nimpossible to differentiate them. Collecting had become the basic \nactivity of both the curious and the connoisseur.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">But Wen Zhenheng need not have worried. Even if purchasers of the \nFujian daily-use encyclopedias had been capable of collecting the \ninscriptions of the famous artists and the ancient Song and Yuan-dynasty\n paintings recommended by <em>Superfluous Things<\/em>, they would have \nbeen able to purchase only a few such works \u2014 certainly their \ncollections could not have extended to the hundred-odd works Wen \nZhenheng knowledgeably sets forth.<sup>87<\/sup>\n And the information on painting and calligraphy presented in these \nencyclopedias was so remote from the knowledge shared in literati social\n circles that, to literati like Wen Zhenheng, it should have posed no \nthreat, nor any need to enforce distinctions.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">For it is clear that the information in the previously discussed \npainting and calligraphy sections of the Fujian daily-use encyclopedias \ndeparts dramatically from the aesthetic knowledge shared by the \nliterati. When it came to seal script and unusual characters, literati \nand scholars possessed knowledge drawn from authoritative historical \nsources and enjoyed distinguishing orthodox from inferior knowledge. \nEven the information on calligraphy in the daily-use encyclopedias \ndesigned for gentry or literati readers was quite solid and precise. The\n <em>Complete Collection of Essential Household Knowledge<\/em> cites nearly the entirety of Jiang Kui\u2019s \u59dc\u5914 (1155-1221) <em>Calligraphy Manual, Continued<\/em> (<em>Xu shu pu<\/em> \u7e8c\u66f8\u8b5c), one of the most famous works in the history of calligraphy.<sup>88<\/sup> <em>Household Essentials<\/em> cites works on calligraphy by recognized authorities like Li Yangbing, Ouyang Xun \u6b50\u967d\u8a62 (557-641), and Jiang Kui.<sup>89<\/sup> <em>Assembled Illustrations of the Three Realms<\/em>\n concisely traces the artistic lineages through which the works of \nimportant calligraphers circulated and spread, making clear the lines of\n transmission of knowledge from master to disciple. <em>Assembled Illustrations<\/em>\n also recommends calligraphic practice models suited to each stage of \nstudy from age eight to age fifteen. Numerous scripts are featured, all \nrepresenting the masterpieces of the past.<sup>90<\/sup><\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">The Fujian daily-use encyclopedias do not begin to supply information\n of this precision or accuracy. The enjoyment of the readers of the \nFujian encyclopedias derived, not from references to authoritative \nsources, but from the visual impact of the \u201cstrange\u201d seal characters \npictured in the encyclopedias; they were unconcerned with origins and \nhistorical accuracy.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">But to a considerable extent it is not the accuracy of the \ninformation in the texts that distinguishes the encyclopedias for gentry\n and literati from the Fujian daily-use encyclopedias. It is the \ndifference in the <em>forms<\/em> the information takes that is most noteworthy. Even if the information in publications such as <em>Assembled Illustrations of the Three Realms<\/em>\n was inaccurate, the forms in which such information was conveyed were \nwell grounded in traditional sources of traceable provenance. The \ninformation is attributed to named, non-fictitious authors; it is \ncomplete, clear, of known origin and development, and accords with a \nChinese knowledge system that emphasizes historical transmission and \nartistic genealogies. Although <em>Assembled Illustrations of the Three Realms<\/em> does not present the roughly one hundred calligraphers and calligraphic practice models found in the <em>Treatise on Superfluous Things<\/em>,\n its selection is sufficient for readers to show off their knowledge; \nand all the information presented is backed by evidence. Further, in <em>Assembled Illustrations<\/em>,\n information on calligraphy is organized into clear and detailed \ncategories such as small, medium, and large regular script, seal script,\n and Mongolian script as well as stone and bronze inscriptions, \ndemonstrating that the knowledge system of the text is mature and \ncomplete. This is not the case in the Fujian daily-use encyclopedias, \nwhich invariably cite ancient calligraphers and theories of calligraphy \nwithout explaining either clearly; and they consistently fail to specify\n particular calligraphic practice models and inscriptions, leaving \nreaders unable to understand a tradition of calligraphy which by the \nlate Ming was already fully systematized and meticulously defined.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">The differences in quality and presentation of information and their \nrelationship to social distinctions seen in the \u201cCalligraphy\u201d sections \nbecome still clearer in \u201cPainting Manual\u201d sections. After all, one had \nto be literate to learn calligraphy, and even though hierarchical \ndistinctions in understanding and appreciation existed, calligraphy was \nultimately an asset shared only by the literate classes. On the other \nhand, literacy is not required to understand painting, though class \ndistinctions remain apparent in matters of artistic taste and cultural \nconsumption.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">A hierarchy of sorts can be established for works that reproduced \npaintings in the late Ming. At the very top would stand the albums of \nminiaturized versions of famous ancient paintings copied by famous \nlate-Ming painters. Such albums, which \u201cmanifested the large within the \nsmall\u201d (<em>\u201cxiao zhong xian da\u201d<\/em> \u5c0f\u4e2d\u73fe\u5927) were painted by artists of \nthe standing of Dong Qichang and Wang Jian \u738b\u9451 (1598-1677), and replicate\n original paintings by the likes of Song dynasty painter Fan Kuan \u8303\u5bec and\n Yuan dynasty painter Wang Meng in the collections of the artists \nthemselves. They are not painting manuals, but rather works that display\n the artistic skill and \u2014 perhaps more importantly \u2014 the aesthetic \ndiscernment of their collector-artists.<sup>91<\/sup><\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">In contrast, the above-mentioned <em>Gu\u2019s Painting Manual<\/em> was, \nas its title indicates, a painting manual designed to educate the reader\n about the great works and artists of China, past and present. Its \nauthor, Gu Bing, was himself a professional painter, a native of \nHangzhou associated with the Zhe \u6d59 school of painting,<sup>92<\/sup>\n a group of conservative academic painters dismissed by the fashionable \nliterati artists of the day. Gu had also at one time served as a painter\n at the imperial court in Beijing. The preface of his manual emphasizes \nhis painstaking efforts to collect the famous paintings pictured in the \nwork, all of which, he implies, are based on actual paintings. In fact, \nresearchers have shown that only a handful of the hundred-odd paintings \nin the manual can be cross-referenced with extant pieces \u2014 and most of \nthese are inaccurate attributions. For instance, the painting <em>Noble Horse<\/em> (<em>Junma<\/em>\n \u99ff\u99ac) by Tang dynasty artist Han Gan \u97d3\u5e79 (ca. 706-783) is obviously \nderived from a work by Ming dynasty court painter Hu Cong \u80e1\u8070 in which \nHan Gan had no hand.<sup>93<\/sup> Many works affect a style <em>similar<\/em>\n to that of the attributed artist, often an artist of the Zhe school or a\n court painter. The collection closely reflects the painting styles Gu \nBing had mastered \u2014 and perhaps the fact that in the Hangzhou region it \nwas easy to obtain paintings of the Zhe school. Given Gu\u2019s social \nidentity and place of origin, it is perhaps not surprising that his \nknowledge of contemporary mainstream literati painters of the Songjiang \nand Wu regions<sup>94<\/sup>\n and of literati painting styles was spotty. In a piece attributed to \nWen Zhengming, the human figures are much larger than the background \nlandscape; but Wen was not known as a painter of human figures, and in \nhis extant paintings, human figures are crudely depicted, distant and \nfew. And the work Gu attributes to Dong Qichang could not be his, as \nboth the composition and the brush technique are absolutely unlike \nDong\u2019s \u2014 there is no indication that he had a hand in the work (Figure \n18). Not only are Gu Bing\u2019s attributions of Ming literati paintings \nerroneous, his statements about earlier Jin (266-420) and Tang dynasty \npainting styles are also inaccurate.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">It is clear that <em>Gu\u2019s Painting Manual,<\/em> unlike the albums \nproduced by literati painters like Dong Qichang and Wang Jian, did not \ncopy actual ancient works in contemporary collections. The pieces in <em>Gu\u2019s Painting Manual<\/em>\n are not signed, nor do they display any collectors\u2019 seals. The sizes of\n the paintings have been standardized; there are none with unusual \ndimensions. Gu Bing\u2019s claims notwithstanding, these are not \nreproductions of specific works, but attempts to represent the general \nstyles of different artists. <em>Gu\u2019s Painting Manual<\/em> tells us \nnothing about the collection or appreciation of actual works of art in \nthe Ming dynasty. But it does tell us a great deal about the popular \ncontemporary understanding of the history of painting and artistic \nstyles.<sup>95<\/sup><\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">In that it has no connection with the collection or appreciation of actual artwork, <em>Gu\u2019s Painting Manual<\/em>\n clearly stands apart from the aesthetic debates and tastes of elite \nliterati of the late Ming and belongs to a social realm distinct from \nthat of the <em>Treatise on Superfluous Things.<\/em> As mentioned, at \nthat time, discourse on painting and calligraphy mainly took the form of\n short comments on scrolls and was thus necessarily tied to the \ncollection (or at least the ability to gain access to a collection) of \npainting and calligraphy scrolls. Mainstream discourse on art was \nsustained within the social communities and spheres of activity of \nliterati who gathered to view paintings and calligraphy. Those who \nlacked the ability to collect art could not partake of this life of \nrefinement and taste; and those who could not participate in discussions\n about the identification of painters, calligraphers, and their works \nwere excluded from this discourse.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Yet <em>Gu\u2019s Painting Manual<\/em> nonetheless played a role in \nconstructing ideas about the history of painting. Even though it is full\n of false attributions and inaccuracies, the form in which the \ninformation is presented has a basis in orthodox painting history. The \npractice of writing biographies of artists originated in the fourth \ncentury, so Gu Bing was adhering to at least one tradition in Chinese \npainting history. He cites biographies drawn primarily from two \nestablished sources, <em>Precious Mirror of Illustration<\/em> (<em>Tuhui baojian<\/em> \u5716\u7e6a\u5bf6\u9451, 1365 preface) by Yuan dynasty author Xia Wenyan \u590f\u6587\u5f65 and <em>Precious Mirror of Illustration, Continued<\/em> (<em>Tuhui baojian xubian<\/em>\n \u5716\u6703\u5bf6\u9451\u7e8c\u7de8, 1519 preface) by author Han Ang \u97d3\u6602 of the mid-Ming dynasty. And\n in his biographies he is attentive to artistic lineages, noting (albeit\n not always correctly) the master-student relationships that \nconventionally defined these lineages. <sup>96<\/sup>\n He thus provides readers ignorant of the history of painting and \npainting styles with a way of thinking \u2014 and talking \u2014 about painting \nthat conforms to the conventional, mainstream approaches to those \ntopics.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">A similar point can be made about the <em>Tang Poetry Painting Manual<\/em>.\n This work is not a reliable guide to Chinese painting, as it \nexaggerates the unique qualities of brush and ink to an excessive \ndegree. Yet, as Tang poetry provided the subject matter for paintings \nthat were both in demand on the market and valued for their artistic \nworth in late-Ming Suzhou,<sup>97<\/sup>\n this manual, both in its emphasis on brush and ink and its \nincorporation of poetic subject matter, served as a site of negotiation \nbetween mainstream painting circles and painting history. In an age when\n block printing flourished, the label \u201creproduction\u201d was no black mark, \nand these two types of painting manuals provided people who could not \nafford paintings or works of calligraphy the chance to acquaint \nthemselves with the ideas of the mainstream art world and get some sense\n of the finer things in life.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">In contrast, the sections on painting in the Fujian daily-use \nencyclopedias have little to do with mainstream painting history. While \nthe images in <em>Gu\u2019s Painting Manual<\/em> are not accurate depictions \nof actual paintings and works of calligraphy, they are at least \nrectangular \u2014 roughly the correct shape. But the miniature paintings in \nthe painting manuals of Fujian daily-use encyclopedias like <em>Deep Ocean of Myriad Books<\/em>\n tend to be square, bearing even less resemblance to hand or hanging \nscrolls. The compositions within these squares depart still further from\n those of real paintings and works of calligraphy; they employ different\n compositional principles and bear a greater resemblance to the \ndecorative paintings on stoneware and porcelain, with uniformly \ndistributed imagery and little of the variation in spacing and shading \ncharacteristic of paintings (see Figure 15). The images in the dedicated\n painting albums or manuals are called \u201creproductions\u201d because they are \nintended to be like \u2014 and successful in capturing some of the flavor of \u2014\n an original work. The manuals by Dong Qichang and other painters that \n\u201cmanifest the large within the small\u201d come closest to achieving these \ngoals. <em>Gu\u2019s Painting Manual<\/em> takes second place. The painting \nmanuals in the Fujian daily-use encyclopedias depart so dramatically \nfrom actual paintings that they are best thought of as a distinct \ncategory of visual product. They are absolutely unrelated to the works \ncollected and enjoyed by literati and belong to a very different social \nspace.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<figure class=\"wp-block-image\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" width=\"368\" height=\"613\" src=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image16-1.png\" alt=\"\" class=\"wp-image-201\" srcset=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image16-1.png 368w, https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2020\/08\/image16-1-180x300.png 180w\" sizes=\"auto, (max-width: 368px) 100vw, 368px\" \/><\/figure>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Figure 15: \u201cPainting Manual Model\u201d from the \u201cPainting Manual Section\u201d of <em>Deep Ocean of Myriad Books,<\/em> in <em>Ch\u016bgoku nichiy\u014d ruisho sh\u016bsei,<\/em> 7: 23.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">The \u201cPainting Manual\u201d sections of Fujian daily-use encyclopedias, in \naddition to attempting to reproduce paintings, also include much \ninformation on the appreciation of paintings and their history. Much of \nthis information is simply copied from other texts. As previously \nstated, nine entries, including \u201cTips for Recognizing Paintings,\u201d \u201cTips \nfor Viewing Paintings,\u201d and \u201cPainting Criticism by Fu Xiying\u201d were most \nlikely copied from <em>Expansive Record of the Forest of Affairs<\/em>; \nadditionally, the \u201cTips for Depicting Landscapes\u201d entry is drawn from \nthe work of the same name by Yuan dynasty literati painter Huang \nGongwang \u9ec3\u516c\u671b (1269-1354). Today, it may be tempting to dismiss such \ncopying as a form of plagiarism that diminishes the value of the \nencyclopedias as historical sources, but copying from other texts was \nquite a common \u2014 we might say even a conventional \u2014 practice in \npre-modern China. More to the point, copying from other works does not \nrender a source useless, as Roger Chartier has pointed out. <sup>98<\/sup>\n Copied texts can reveal information about textual circulation, as a \ntext that appears again and again through repeated rounds of copying \nmost likely penetrates a wider range of social spaces, either through \nreading or oral transmission. And copying might open opportunities for \nnew meanings: when a text appears in different publications, its context\n and layout differ, as do the environments within which it is read and \ncirculated; and its effect and meaning change accordingly. Even though \nFujian daily-use encyclopedias reproduce content from other books, these\n reproductions possess a meaning and have an impact that cannot be \nequated with those of the original works.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">In these encyclopedias, information on the appreciation of painting \ngenerally takes the form of rhymed instructions in lines of equal length\n that set forth simple, brief explanations of specific points. \u201cTips for\n Recognizing Paintings\u201d begins by enumerating six requirements (e.g., \n\u201cstyle coupled with strength,\u201d \u201cmature structure,\u201d \u201clustrous color\u201d) and\n six strong points. These six requirements and six strong points first \nappear in the preface to Liu Daochun\u2019s \u5289\u9053\u9187 <em>Criticism of Famous Paintings of This Sage Dynasty<\/em> (<em>Sheng chao ming hua ping<\/em> \u8056\u671d\u540d\u756b\u8a55), an eleventh-century work that sets forth a thorough process for recognizing and appreciating paintings.<sup>99<\/sup>\n In the late Ming, the Fujian daily-use encyclopedias extract and \ntruncate portions of the original text in a way that distorts and \nradically over-simplifies its meaning, presenting it in the form of \nsimple, easily memorized rhymed verses identified by number. The most \ninfluential criteria for the evaluation of Chinese painting, Xie He\u2019s \u8b1d\u8d6b\n \u201cSix Principles of Chinese Painting,\u201d receive no better treatment: the \nsix principles are removed from Xie\u2019s famous sixth-century work, <em>Classification of Ancient Paintings<\/em> (<em>Guhua pinlu<\/em> \u53e4\u756b\u54c1\u9304), <sup>100<\/sup>\n and presented, like Liu Daochun\u2019s requirements, in six rhyming lines of\n four characters each. Moreover, the title of Xie He\u2019s famous \nformulation is frequently inaccurately reproduced as \u201cPaintings Have Six\n Patterns.\u201d<sup>101<\/sup>\n To return to the earlier point about the significance of copying, these\n \u201cmiscopyings\u201d and distortions of important standards of art \nappreciation clearly did make a difference. How else are we to explain \nGao Lian\u2019s critique of the six laws, six requirements, and six strengths\n in his <em>Eight Treatises on Nurturing Life<\/em>? \u201cTo discuss \npaintings on this basis is to degrade them,\u201d he writes. Gao Lian, born \nin Hangzhou to a wealthy family, gained renown for his art collection \nand was recognized as a person of cultural refinement.<sup>102<\/sup>\n Clearly the target of his derision was not the original \u2014 and firmly \northodox \u2014 six laws and six requirements of Xie He and Liu Daochun, but \nthe mutilated version of them published in the Fujian daily-use \nencyclopedias.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">The entries \u201cTips for Viewing Paintings\u201d and \u201cEssentials of \nRecognizing Paintings\u201d in the Fujian encyclopedias are also excerpted \nfrom different parts of the preface to <em>Criticism of Paintings of This Sage Dynasty.<\/em>\n They present very general principles for appreciation: \u201cWhen viewing an\n inferior work, do not speak ill of it, but seek its strengths; when \nviewing a superior work, do not praise it, but seek its flaws.\u201d Somewhat\n more specifically, they make short statements about how to appreciate \npaintings of different subjects, mentioning, for example, the majesty \nand merciful air of Buddhist and Daoist paintings and the beauty and \nleisurely quality of paintings of flowers and bamboo. The entry \n\u201cPainting Criticism by Fu Xiying\u201d opines that \u201cthere should be no slopes\n on distant mountains, no waves on distant water, and no eyes on distant\n birds,\u201d but that \u201cthe scales of fish should be brightly colored\u201d and \n\u201cthe scales of dragons should flash like coins.\u201d These simple rules for \nthe most part address the physical appearance of the paintings\u2019 \nsubjects, enabling readers to distinguish them visually. There is no \nneed here for the reader to know anything of art history \u2014 that is, to \nbe able to recognize iconology or the transmission of styles between \npainters. Indeed, there are no references to specific painters or \npaintings here.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Moreover, the \u201cPainting Manual\u201d sections of the Fujian daily-use \nencyclopedias are riddled with errors. They refer to the \u201cSix Patterns\u201d \nrather than the \u201cSix Laws,\u201d revealing a lack of familiarity with an \nessential set of principles of Chinese painting discourse. The \u201cFamous \nPaintings of the Past and Present\u201d entry misprints the name of the Tang \ndynasty painter Li Zhaodao \u674e\u8a54\u9053 (675-758).<sup>103<\/sup> Yet the work that the encyclopedias were copying, the <em>Expansive Record of the Forest of Affairs<\/em>,\n makes no such mistakes, either about the \u201cSix Laws\u201d or Li Zhaodao. \nOther errors include a number of mistaken characters in citations from \nHuang Gongwang\u2019s \u201cTips for Depicting Landscapes.\u201d For instance, the \nphrase \u201cthe <em>cunfa<\/em> \u76b4\u6cd5 technique of depicting textures involves \nletting the ink seep, forming wrinkles\u201d has a mistaken character, making\n the sentence unintelligible.<sup>104<\/sup>\n The most startling error is the writing of the personal name of Gu \nKaizhi as \u201cKai,\u201d omitting the final character. Gu is one of the most \nfamous painters in Chinese history (and the first painter listed in <em>Gu\u2019s Painting Manual<\/em>), and his position as such was firmly established as early as the Tang dynasty.<sup>105<\/sup>\n Missing characters and missing sentences further complicate efforts to \nfollow the text in full. Indifferent to quality, the Fujian publishers \npursued profits through low production costs, high print runs, and \nspeed, and the result was naturally error-ridden texts. The errors \nlisted above were not technically difficult to correct, but the Fujian \npublishers never corrected them, revealing that they were unconcerned \nwith petty matters such as accuracy and conformity to orthodox painting \nhistory \u2014 and, more to the point, that there was a social space for such\n erroneous information to exist.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">But there is one interesting way in which the Fujian encyclopedias \nwere in a sense participating in the construction of Chinese art \nhistory. Most of the eighteen painters of the past and present featured \nin the \u201cFamous Paintings of Past and Present\u201d entry in the late-Ming \nencyclopedias are drawn from the entry of the same name in the <em>Expansive Record from the Forest of Literati.<\/em>\n The sole exception is Chen Zihe \u9673\u5b50\u548c, whose name is newly added; he is \nidentified as a painter of celestial beings. The inclusion of Ming \ndynasty painter Chen Zihe among mostly Jin and Tang dynasty painters is \nunusual in itself, and it is still more curious that Chen Zihe is the \nonly contemporary painter selected for inclusion. Chen Zihe, from \nPucheng, Fujian, was active in the early and mid-sixteenth century. \nClassified as a professional painter of the Zhe school, his works \ninclude <em>The Air of an Immortal<\/em> (<em>Shuyou xianqi<\/em> \u6b8a\u6709\u4ed9\u6c23).<sup>106<\/sup>\n He was indeed known for his depictions of immortals, but literati from \nthe lower Yangzi delta region had, as early as the mid-sixteenth \ncentury, dismissed him as unworthy of attention for practicing \u201ca \nmisguided, disgraceful approach\u201d to painting. His name was included in a\n list of Zhe school painters whose works were not to be studied or \nviewed.<sup>107<\/sup>\n Why then does he appear, alone among all Ming painters, in these \nencyclopedias? Geography appears to be the reason: Pucheng, his \nbirthplace, is located in the northwestern mountainous region of Fujian,\n near Jianyang, the major site of Fujian publishing in the late Ming. \nThe inclusion of Chen Zihe among the towering greats of Chinese painting\n history demonstrates that, despite the commercial connections and \ntextual exchanges between Jianyang and Jiangnan publishers and the \nintegration of the southeast China book market, Fujian publishers did \nnot always follow the lead of Jiangnan, despite its leading cultural \nposition in the Ming empire. The daily-use encyclopedias from Jianyang \nmaintained a unique regional flavor.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">As we have seen, however misguided Gu Bing\u2019s efforts to reproduce \nfamous paintings were, he was working within the bounds of orthodox \npainting history when he selected the painters to represent in <em>Gu\u2019s Painting Manual<\/em>.\n But the painting-related contents of the late-Ming Fujian daily-use \nencyclopedias lie outside orthodox painting historical discourse; \nneither the form nor the content of the information they presented would\n have been accepted by figures like Dong Qichang and Gao Lian, major \nparticipants and directors of mainstream artistic discourse. Yet the \nclose relationship between the publishing industries of Jianyang and \nJiangnan refutes the notion that the Fujian publishers were unfamiliar \nwith mainstream knowledge of and the discourse on painting history \ncurrent in Jiangnan. We are led to assume, then, that, in their \nencyclopedias, these men \u2014 shrewd judges of the book market \u2014 were \ncarving out a social space distinct from that of mainstream painting and\n calligraphy discourse. While their readers were aware of contemporary \ntrends, their ignorance or imperfect knowledge of cultural touchstones \nin painting and calligraphy set them apart from the elite class, at the \nsame time that their new purchasing power made them an attractive target\n audience for works that promised to give them at least a glimpse of \nwhat they were missing.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<h2 class=\"wp-block-heading\" id=\"conclusion-cultural-products-and-social-spaces\">Conclusion: Cultural Products and Social Spaces<\/h2>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Large numbers of cultural products irrelevant to the necessities of \nlife were in vogue in late-Ming society; commercial publications are \njust one example. The aspect of these cultural products that proves most\n difficult to research is not their production, but their consumption. \nThis is especially true in the case of crude, inexpensive publications \nlike the Fujian daily-use encyclopedias, because contemporary documents \ndo not contain sales figures or data on regional distribution and \nbecause there are no records of readers\u2019 feedback. Hence researchers \nstruggle to gauge the extent of their circulation and social impact. \nHowever, as with any product, the thing itself provides clues to its own\n consumption. Publishers, in the early stages of production, had to plan\n how to market their works by estimating market demand and targeting \npotential consumers. This planning was then clearly displayed in a \nbook\u2019s precise content and form of compilation \u2014 that is, in the \npublishing strategies designed to attract readers to the work. As soon \nas a book appears on the market, it faces competitors, and publishers \ncould also use their assessment of this competition to further shape \ntheir products for the most desirable audience \u2014 that is, the audience \nlikeliest to yield the greatest profit. Therefore, gathering examples of\n the same genre of text and analyzing their contents and form and \nidentifying their similarities and differences is an important way of \ndetermining their purchasers and their circulation. As books become \ncultural products upon entering the marketplace, and people purchased \nand read them, they generated social practices and reading behaviors \nthat provide us with a means to survey social spaces.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">This project is similar to that of Pierre Bourdieu\u2019s well-known <em>Distinction: A Social Critique of the Judgement of Taste,<\/em>\n which attempts to explore and delineate social spaces through the forms\n taken by cultural products. Using a questionnaire to survey the \ncultural consumption of people of various classes and professions, \nBourdieu selects cultural products such as music and paintings as they \nare divided into distinct classical and contemporary or elite and \npopular forms and uses these distinctions to gauge different consumer \ngroups and social spaces.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">There are no questionnaires to aid in research on the Fujian \ndaily-use encyclopedias of the late-Ming dynasty or in the analysis of \nthe relationship between people of different classes and consumption of \ncultural products. However, the duplication of content and layout among \nthe encyclopedias and their uniform level of quality make it possible to\n carry out cluster analysis. A detailed investigation of the content and\n form of many of these encyclopedias leads to the finding that they bear\n some resemblance to <em>Expansive Record of the Forest of Affairs,<\/em> in that they were published in Fujian and often reproduce portions of the <em>Expansive Record.<\/em> But ultimately the late-Ming texts distort the original meaning of the <em>Expansive Record<\/em>.\n They define both knowledge and lifestyle differently; and they sold on \nthe market for different prices and to different consumers. The \ndaily-use encyclopedias with \u201cdomestic\u201d (<em>jujia<\/em> \u5c45\u5bb6, also \n\u201cfamilial\u201d) in the title were aimed at a landed gentry readership and \nemphasize the administration of household enterprises and children\u2019s \neducation. On the other hand, the exquisitely printed <em>Assembled Illustrations of the Three Realms<\/em>\n was, in the information it purveyed, oriented toward the literati and \nscholarly class and its traditions. Both these types of daily-use \nencyclopedias \u2014 the domestic and the scholarly \u2014 are dramatically \ndifferent from the Fujian daily-use encyclopedias. The former two types \nare grounded in traditional Chinese ideas and their associated \nlifestyles \u2014 and it is precisely for that reason that Fujian publishers \nwith sharp business minds were able to seize on a gap in the book market\n and produce a new type of daily-use encyclopedia suited to contemporary\n sociocultural and lifestyle demands.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Indeed, Fujian daily-use encyclopedias appeared for reasons closely \nrelated to new social and cultural trends of the late Ming, most \nparticularly to the rise of cities as centers of cultural transmission \nand sites of social interaction and the marketplace of ideas. The \nthirty-some extant Fujian daily-use encyclopedias appeared at just the \nright time to engage in dialogue with these new phenomena, meeting a \ndemand among the lower-level literates with a bit of extra pocket money \nto appear knowledgeable about and perhaps even to participate in the \nlatest social trends. But these works also enhanced and perpetuated the \nnew cultural phenomena, discovering and creating an alternative social \nspace \u2014 as we saw in the departure from mainstream discourse in the \npainting and calligraphy sections of the works. This social space is \ndistinct from that of the society and culture of the highest elite \nclasses that have been the main focus of previous scholarship. In other \nwords, the social space of that portion of the population that could \nread and had the ability to consume cultural products remained divided. \nDespite the fact that this space was traditionally seen as homogeneous, \nit is now apparent that it was marked by clear social divisions, \nparticularly with regard to arts and culture.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Can it be said, then, that the social space specific to Fujian \ndaily-use encyclopedias is part of \u201cpopular culture?\u201d According to Roger\n Chartier, scholars today use the term \u201cpopular culture\u201d \u2014incorrectly &#8212;\n to refer to the intellectual class, failing to take into account the \nculture of the illiterate population. Chartier further points out two \ncontradictory views taken by previous studies of German popular culture,\n both in fact informed by similar assumptions: first, popular culture is\n seen as independent, that is, entirely divorced from high culture, and \nsimultaneously, it is believed that high culture controls culture and \nsociety in general \u2014 that is, that the masses accept its enlightened \nteachings and passively receive mainstream culture. Both assumptions \ntake the view that popular culture is monolithic, standing in diametric \nopposition to high culture, that certain things are intrinsically a part\n of \u201cpopular culture,\u201d and that \u201cpopular culture\u201d as researchers \nconceive it reflects an accurate understanding of popular culture.<sup>108<\/sup>\n There are also cases in which studies of late-Ming culture make these \ntwo assumptions. For instance, when discussing morality books,<sup>109<\/sup> precious scrolls,<sup>110<\/sup>\n and daily-use encyclopedias, some scholars tend to see such texts as \npart of popular culture, even to believe that they reflect the lives of \nthe common people, as if \u201cpopular culture\u201d were a single unified \nconcept, and as if there were no need to compare them in order to \nidentify competition and coordination among these publications. But \nother scholars assume that texts like morality books are subject to a \nsignificant influence by upper-class culture and that they represent the\n diffusion and popularization of orthodox Confucian thought \u2014 that is, \nthat Confucian education plays a guiding role, and morality books and \ndaily-use encyclopedias are the products of its popularization.<\/p>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Rather than assuming as a matter of course that Fujian daily-use \nencyclopedias of the late Ming are part of \u201cpopular culture,\u201d we should \nstudy them in detail to determine their readership and the nature of the\n information they present. These publications targeted people who were \nliterate, able to consume cultural products, and had the leisure and \nability to know of the latest trends in social life \u2014although their \nability to participate in these trends was limited. They may not have \nbeen upper-class, highly educated people, but they interacted to some \nextent with upper-class culture; the two populations occupied distinct \nsocial spaces that overlapped in complex ways. The market competition \nbetween Fujian daily-use encyclopedias and other types of encyclopedias \nhints, too, at the existence of different groups of consumers occupying \ndifferent social spaces, just as the ways in which these works distorted\n the original meaning of the works they copied alert us to the existence\n of distinct classes of information. The results of this detailed \nresearch could not have been obtained through an approach assuming a \ndiametric opposition between \u201cpopular culture\u201d and \u201chigh culture.\u201d<\/p>\n\n\n\n<hr class=\"wp-block-separator\"\/>\n\n\n\n<ol class=\"wp-block-list\"><li><sup>\u2217<\/sup>This paper is the product of research  conducted under a subprogram of the themed program \u201cMing and Qing  societies and lifestyles\u201d of the Institute of Modern History, Academia  Sinica. Thank you to the general director of the program and the  participating scholars for their three years of continued effort. A  draft of this paper was presented at the international academic  conference \u201cLifestyles, ideas, and Chinese modernity\u201d hosted by the  Institute of Modern History (November 2002). Thank you to the scholars  in attendance, especially Professor Hsiung Ping-chen, for their valuable  feedback. Thanks are due as well to Professors Cynthia Brokaw, Dorothy  Ko, Bai Qianshen, and Shang Wei, and to my two classmates Ma Meng-ching  and Chen Dexin. They have contributed greatly to the completeness of  this paper, and I wish here to extend thanks to them all.<\/li><li> For a comparison of <em>Shilin guangji<\/em> editions  and their content, see Hu Daojing \u80e1\u9053\u975c, \u201c1963 nian Zhonghua Shuju  yingyinben qianyan\u201d 1963 \u5e74\u4e2d\u83ef\u66f8\u5c40\u5f71\u5370\u672c\u524d\u8a00, in Chen Yuanjing \u9673\u5143\u975a, <em>Shilin guangji<\/em>  \u4e8b\u6797\u5ee3\u8a18 (1340 edition by the Zheng family\u2019s Jichengtang publishing house)  (Beijing: Zhonghua Shuju, 1999), 559-565; Morita Kenji \u68ee\u7530\u61b2\u53f8, \u201cGuanyu zai  Riben de <em>Shilin guangji<\/em> zhu ben\u201d \u95dc\u65bc\u5728\u65e5\u672c\u7684\u300a\u4e8b\u6797\u5ee3\u8a18\u300b\u8af8\u672c, in <em>Shilin guangji<\/em>, 566-572. For more on Morita\u2019s views, see \u201c<em>Shilin guangji<\/em> no shohanbon ni tsuite: Kokunai shoz\u014d no shohon o ch\u016bshin ni\u201d \u300c\u4e8b\u6797\u5e83\u8a18\u300d\u306e\u8af8\u7248\u672c\u306b\u3064\u3044\u3066\u2014\u2014\u56fd\u5185\u6240\u8535\u306e\u8af8\u672c\u3092\u4e2d\u5fc3\u306b, in <em>S\u014ddai no chishikijin: Shis\u014d, seido, chiiki shakai<\/em>  \u5b8b\u4ee3\u306e\u77e5\u8b58\u4eba\u2014\u2014\u601d\u60f3\u30fb\u5236\u5ea6\u30fb\u5730\u57df\u793e\u91d1 (Tokyo: Ky\u016bko Shoin, 1993), 287-317; see also Wu  Huey-fang [Wu Huifang] \u5433\u8525\u82b3, \u201cMinjian riyong leishu de yuanyuan yu  fazhan\u201d \u6c11\u9593\u65e5\u7528\u985e\u66f8\u7684\u6df5\u6e90\u8207\u767c\u5c55, <em>Guoli Zhengzhi Daxue lishi xuebao<\/em> \u570b\u7acb\u653f\u6cbb\u5927\u5b78\u6b77\u53f2\u5b78\u5831 18 (2001): 7-10.<\/li><li>In addition to the studies by Hu Daojing and Morita  Kenji cited in the previous footnote, the woodblock editions of the Zhan  family\u2019s Jindejingshe \u9032\u5fb7\u7cbe\u820d publishing house and the Xiyuanjingshe \u897f\u5712\u7cbe\u820d  publishing house held by the Fu Ssu-nien Library of the Institute of  History and Philology, Academia Sinica were also issued by commercial  booksellers in the Jianyang, Fujian region. Regarding Jindejingshe, see  Xie Shuishun \u8b1d\u6c34\u9806 and Li Ting \u674e\u73fd, <em>Fujian gudai keshu<\/em> \u798f\u5efa\u53e4\u4ee3\u523b\u66f8  (Fuzhou: Fujian People\u2019s Publishing House, 1997), 317. Xiyuanjingshe may  have been owned by the Yu family, the great publishing family of  Jianyang; see Du Xinfu \u675c\u4fe1\u5b5a, ed., <em>Mingdai banke zonglu<\/em> \u660e\u4ee3\u7248\u523b\u7d9c\u9304 (Yangzhou: Jiangsu Guangling Guji Chubanshe, 1983), 2: 8; Lucille Chia<em>, Printing for Profit: The Commercial Publishers of Jianyang, Fujian<\/em> <em>(11<sup>th<\/sup>-17<sup>th<\/sup> centuries)<\/em>  (Cambridge MA: Harvard University Asia Center for Harvard-Yenching  Institute, 2002), 231. Both booksellers were active in the early and  mid-Ming dynasty.<\/li><li>See the previously cited papers by Hu Daojing and Morita Kenji as well as Chia, <em>Printing for profit<\/em>, 360, note 110.<\/li><li> See Morita, \u201cGuanyu zai Riben de <em>Shilin guangji<\/em> zhu ben,\u201d 571. Regarding publications by the Yu family\u2019s Jingxiantang publishing house, see Du, <em>Mingdai banke zonglu<\/em>, 6: 38. The Yu family was an important family of commercial booksellers in the Fujian region from the Song dynasty to the Ming.<\/li><li>See Ashida K\u014dsh\u014d \u8606\u7530\u5b5d\u662d, \u201cMindai kanpon ni okeru binpon no ichi\u201d \u660e\u4ee3\u520a\u672c\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u95a9\u672c\u306e\u4f4d\u7f6e, <em>Tianli Tushuguanbao Biblia<\/em> \u5929\u7406\u5716\u66f8\u9928\u5831Biblia 95 (Nov. 1990): 91-93; Chia, <em>Printing for Profit,<\/em> 39-42, 52-62.<\/li><li>This point and the discussion that follows are based on  the Xiyuanjingshe woodblock edition held by the Institute of History and  Philology, Academia Sinica.<\/li><li>This format was employed by Fujian publishers particularly in illustrated editions of popular <em>pinghua<\/em> \u5e73\u8a71 tales (\u201cplain talks,\u201d from their origins in oral literature), from the Song dynasty onward. Chia, <em>Printing for Profit,<\/em> 40-42, 193-220.<\/li><li>On the late-Ming daily-use encyclopedias referred to  here and below, in addition to the previously cited editions, see Xu  Huiying \u5f90\u6703\u701b, ed., <em>Xinqie Yantai jiaozheng tianxia tongxing wenlin jubao wanjuan xingluo<\/em> \u65b0\u9365\u71d5\u81fa\u6821\u6b63\u5929\u4e0b\u901a\u884c\u6587\u6797\u805a\u5bf6\u842c\u5377\u661f\u7f85 (serial woodblock edition of 1600), in <em>Beijing Tushuguan guji zhenben congkan<\/em>  \u5317\u4eac\u5716\u66f8\u9928\u53e4\u7c4d\u73cd\u672c\u53e2\u520a (Beijing: Shumu Wenxian Chubanshe, 1998), 76: 113-405,  which consists of the previously cited edition held by the National  Library of China in Beijing; the 1610 <em>Xinke quanbu shimin beilan bianyong wenlin huijin wanshu yuanhai<\/em> \u65b0\u523b\u5168\u90e8\u58eb\u6c11\u5099\u89bd\u4fbf\u7528\u6587\u6797\u5f59\u9326\u842c\u66f8\u6df5\u6d77 (abbreviated hereafter as <em>Wanshu yuanhai<\/em>) held by the National Library of China in Beijing; and the 1614 serial edition <em>Xinke souluo wuche hebing wanbao quanshu<\/em> \u65b0\u523b\u641c\u7f85\u4e94\u8eca\u5408\u4f75\u842c\u5bf6\u5168\u66f8 (abbreviated hereafter as <em>Wuche wanbao quanshu<\/em>). The latter two are included in Sakade Yoshinobu \u5742\u51fa\u7965\u4f38 and Ogawa Y\u014dichi \u5c0f\u5ddd\u967d\u4e00, eds., <em>Ch\u016bgoku nichiy\u014d ruisho sh\u016bsei<\/em>  \u4e2d\u56fd\u65e5\u7528\u985e\u66f8\u96c6\u6210 (Tokyo: Ky\u016bko shoten, 1999-2004). Despite some differences in  content, the various editions are nonetheless very similar.<\/li><li>On the circulation of images and the importance of visual representation in late-Ming culture, see Craig Clunas, <em>Pictures and visuality in early modern China<\/em> (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1997), 25-76; Ma Meng-ching \u99ac\u5b5f\u6676, \u201cEr mu zhi wan: Cong <em>Xixiang ji<\/em> banhua chatu lun wan Ming chuban wenhua dui shijuexing de guanzhu\u201d \u8033\u76ee\u4e4b\u73a9\uff1a\u5f9e\u3008\u897f\u5ec2\u8a18\u3009\u7248\u756b\u63d2\u5716\u8ad6\u665a\u660e\u51fa\u7248\u6587\u5316\u5c0d\u8996\u89ba\u6027\u7684\u95dc\u6ce8, <em>Meishushi yanjiu jikan<\/em> \u7f8e\u8853\u53f2\u7814\u7a76\u96c6\u520a 13 (2002): 202-276.<\/li><li>For a summarized comparison of Fujian daily-use encyclopedias of the late Ming and <em>Shilin guangji<\/em>, see Wu, \u201cMinjian riyong leishu de yuanyuan yu fazhan,\u201d 13-14.<\/li><li> On late-Ming <em>qinglou<\/em> culture, see Wang  Hung-tai \u738b\u9d3b\u6cf0, \u201cLiudong yu hudong: You Ming Qing jian chengshi shenghuo  de texing tance gongzhong changyu de zhankai\u201d  \u6d41\u52d5\u8207\u4e92\u52d5\u2014\u2014\u7531\u660e\u6e05\u9593\u57ce\u5e02\u751f\u6d3b\u7684\u7279\u6027\u63a2\u6e2c\u516c\u773e\u5834\u57df\u7684\u5c55\u958b (Master\u2019s thesis, National Taiwan University  Graduate School of History, Taipei, Nov. 1998), 246-291; Wang Hung-tai  \u738b\u9d3b\u6cf0, \u201cQinglou: Zhongguo wenhua de houhuayuan\u201d \u9752\u6a13\u2014\u2014\u4e2d\u570b\u6587\u5316\u7684\u5f8c\u82b1\u5712, <em>Dangdai<\/em> \u7576\u4ee3 137 (Jan. 1999): 16-29.<\/li><li> See \u201cChuban shuoming\u201d \u51fa\u7248\u8aaa\u660e, <em>Jujia biyong shilei<\/em>  \u5c45\u5bb6\u5fc5\u7528\u4e8b\u985e (1560 woodblock edition with preface by Tian Rucheng; Kyoto:  Zhongwen Chubanshe, 1984), no page numbers; Wu, \u201cMinjian riyong leishu  de yuanyuan yu fazhan,\u201d 9-10.<\/li><li>See Zhang Tingyu \u5f35\u5ef7\u7389 et al., eds., <em>Ming shi<\/em>  \u660e\u53f2, 24: 7372. According to Tian Rucheng, this edition was published by  Hong Zimei (courtesy name). Hong, personal name Geng, was born in  Qiantang into a wealthy family that collected and engraved books. See  Du, <em>Mingdai banke zonglu<\/em>, 3: 23.<\/li><li>See Tian Rucheng \u7530\u6c5d\u6210, \u201cJujia biyong shilei xu\u201d \u5c45\u5bb6\u5fc5\u7528\u4e8b\u985e\u6558, <em>Jujia biyong shilei<\/em> \u5c45\u5bb6\u5fc5\u7528\u4e8b\u985e, 1-2.<\/li><li> According to Wu Huey-fang\u2019s paper \u201cMinjian riyong leishu de yuanyuan yu fazhan,\u201d there is a 1579 serial edition of <em>Jujia biyong shilei quanji<\/em>,  but as this could not be located in Taiwan, I have no choice but to  exclude it from this discussion. A comparison of the four available  versions shows that their content is identical. See Unknown, <em>Jujia biyong shilei quanji<\/em> \u5c45\u5bb6\u5fc5\u7528\u4e8b\u985e\u5168\u96c6, in <em>Beijing Tushuguan guji zhenben congkan<\/em> \u5317\u4eac\u5716\u66f8\u9928\u53e4\u7c4d\u73cd\u672c\u53e2\u520a (Ming dynasty woodblock edition; Beijing: Shumu Wenxian Chubanshe, 1988), 61: 1-422; <em>Jujia biyong shilei quanji<\/em>, in <em>Siku quanshu cunmu congshu: Zibu<\/em> \u56db\u5eab\u5168\u66f8\u5b58\u76ee\u53e2\u66f8,\u5b50\u90e8 (Ming dynasty woodblock edition, Tainan County: Zhuangyan Wenhua Shiye Youxian Gongsi, 1995), 117: 28-444; <em>Jujia biyong shilei<\/em> (1560 edition with preface by Tian Rucheng); <em>Jujia biyong shilei quanji<\/em>, in <em>Xuxiu siku quanshu<\/em> \u7e8c\u4fee\u56db\u5eab\u5168\u66f8 (1568 woodblock edition; Shanghai, Shanghai Guju Chubanshe, 1997), 1184: 309-728. An edition of <em>Jujia biyong shilei quanji<\/em>  excavated from the tomb of a Mr. Shi and his wife in Nanzhuan Village,  Taicang, Jiangsu includes the preface by Tian Rucheng. Shi passed away  in 1631 after spending his entire life as a reclusive scholar, never  taking up an official post. Other books excavated from the tomb include <em>Gujin kao<\/em> \u53e4\u4eca\u8003and <em>Zhanguoce suoyin<\/em>  \u6230\u570b\u7b56\u7d22\u5f15; it is clearly the book collection of a country gentleman. This  demonstrates the extent of the distribution of the woodblock edition of <em>Jujia biyong shilei quanji<\/em>  with Tian\u2019s preface, and also gives a glimpse of the characteristics of  readers. Wu Yuming \u5433\u807f\u660e, \u201cTaicang Nanzhuan Cun Mingmu ji chutu guji\u201d  \u592a\u5009\u5357\u8f49\u6751\u660e\u5893\u53ca\u51fa\u571f\u53e4\u7c4d, <em>Wenwu<\/em> \u6587\u7269 3 (1987): 19-22.<\/li><li>See Song Xu \u5b8b\u8a61, <em>Song Shi jiayao bu, jiayi bu, jiagui bu, yanxian bu<\/em> \u5b8b\u6c0f\u5bb6\u8981\u90e8\u30fb\u5bb6\u5100\u90e8\u30fb\u5bb6\u898f\u90e8\u30fb\u71d5\u9592\u90e8, in <em>Beijing Tushuguan guji zhenben congkan<\/em> \u5317\u4eac\u5716\u66f8\u9928\u53e4\u7c4d\u73cd\u672c\u53e2\u520a, 61: 3-69.<\/li><li>Qu You, courtesy name Zongji \u5b97\u5409, was from Qiantang  (modern Hangzhou), and renowned in his time as a poet. Qu does not state  that the preface was written specifically for <em>Household Essentials<\/em>, but it is placed before the main text, demonstrating that the publisher approved of its content.<\/li><li>The ownership of the Xinyuantang is not known. Only one  of its other publications is extant, an early seventeenth-century  edition of the collected works of the early-Ming intellectual Tang  Wenfeng \u5510\u6587\u9cf3of She County.<\/li><li>Chia, <em>Printing for profit<\/em>, 250-253.<\/li><li>For instance, <em>Bianmin tuzuan<\/em> \u4fbf\u6c11\u5716\u7e82, in <em>Zhongguo gudai banhua congkan<\/em> \u4e2d\u570b\u53e4\u4ee3\u7248\u756b\u53e2\u520a (Shanghai: Shanghai Guji Chubanshe, 1985), 887-995.<\/li><li>See Wang Qi \u738b\u573b, Wang Siyi \u738b\u601d\u7fa9, eds., <em>Sancai tuhui<\/em> \u4e09\u624d\u5716\u6703 (Shanghai: Shanghai Guji Chubanshe, 1985), 1: 1-11.<\/li><li>See Sakai Tadao \u9152\u4e95\u5fe0\u592b, \u201cMindai no nichiy\u014d ruisho to shomin ky\u014diku\u201d \u660e\u4ee3\u306e\u65e5\u7528\u985e\u66f8\u3068\u5eb6\u6c11\u6559\u80b2, in <em>Kinsei Ch\u016bgoku ky\u014dikushi kenky\u016b<\/em> \u8fd1\u4e16\u4e2d\u56fd\u6559\u80b2\u53f2\u7814\u7a76, ed. Hayashi Tomoharu \u6797\u53cb\u6625 (Tokyo: Kokudosha, 1958), 87-89.<\/li><li>See Isobe Akira \u78ef\u90e8\u5f70, \u201cMinmatsu ni okeru <em>Saiy\u016bki<\/em>  no shutaiteki juy\u014ds\u014d ni kansuru kenky\u016b: Mindai \u2018kotenteki hakuwa  sh\u014dsetsu\u2019 no dokushas\u014d o meguru mondai ni tsuite\u201d  \u660e\u672b\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u300e\u897f\u904a\u8a18\u300f\u306e\u4e3b\u4f53\u7684\u53d7\u5bb9\u5c64\u306b\u95a2\u3059\u308b\u7814\u7a76\u2014\u2014\u660e\u4ee3\u300c\u53e4\u5178\u7684\u767d\u8a71\u5c0f\u8aac\u300d\u306e\u8aad\u8005\u5c64\u3092\u3081\u3050\u308b\u554f\u984c\u306b\u3064\u3044\u3066, <em>Sh\u016bkan T\u014dy\u014dgaku<\/em> \u96c6\u520a\u6771\u6d0b\u5b66 44 (1980): 55; \u5f35\u79c0\u6c11 Zhang Xiumin, <em>Zhongguo yinshua shi<\/em>  \u4e2d\u570b\u5370\u5237\u53f2 (Shanghai: People\u2019s Publishing House, 1989), 518; \u014cki Yasushi  \u5927\u6728\u5eb7, \u201cMinmatsu K\u014dnan ni okeru shuppan bunka no keny\u016b\u201d \u660e\u672b\u6c5f\u5357\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u51fa\u7248\u6587\u5316\u306e\u7814\u7a76, <em>Hiroshima Daigaku Bungakubu kiy\u014d<\/em> \u5e83\u5cf6\u5927\u5b66\u6587\u5b66\u90e8\u7d00\u8981 50 (1991): 102-108; Dorothy Ko, <em>Teachers of the Inner Chambers: Women and Culture in Seventeenth-Century China<\/em> (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1994), 35-37; Shen Jin \u6c88\u6d25, \u201cMing dai fangke tushu zhi liutong yu jiage\u201d \u660e\u4ee3\u574a\u523b\u5716\u66f8\u4e4b\u6d41\u901a\u8207\u50f9\u683c, <em>Guojia Tushuguan guankan<\/em> \u570b\u5bb6\u5716\u66f8\u9928\u9928\u520a vol. 85, no. 1 (1996): 101-118; Chia, <em>Printing for profit<\/em>, 190-192; Inoue Susumu \u4e95\u4e0a\u9032, <em>Ch\u016bgoku shuppan bunkashi: Shomotsu sekai to chi no f\u016bkei<\/em> \u4e2d\u56fd\u51fa\u7248\u6587\u5316\u53f2\u2014\u2014\u66f8\u7269\u4e16\u754c\u3068\u77e5\u306e\u98a8\u666f (Nagoya: Nagoya Daigaku Shuppankai, 2002), 262-266.<\/li><li>See Isobe, \u201cMinmatsu ni okeru <em>Saiy\u016bki<\/em> no shutaiteki juy\u014ds\u014d ni kansuru kenky\u016b,\u201d 55-56; Shen Jin, \u201cMing dai fangke tushu zhi liutong yu jiage,\u201d 116-118.<\/li><li>See Ko, <em>Teachers of the Inner Chambers,<\/em> 35-37.<\/li><li>Xi Zhousheng \u897f\u5468\u751f, ed., Huang Suqiu \u9ec3\u8085\u79cb, annotation, <em>Xingshi yinyuan zhuan<\/em>  \u9192\u4e16\u59fb\u7de3\u50b3 (Shanghai: Shanghai Guji Chubanshe, 1983), vol. 1, 2. Ogawa  Y\u014dichi also cites this passage in his book but takes a different  perspective. See Ogawa Y\u014dichi \u5c0f\u5ddd\u967d\u4e00 <em>Nichiy\u014d ruisho ni yoru Shin Min dai sh\u014dsetsu no kenky\u016b<\/em>  \u65e5\u7528\u985e\u66f8\u306b\u3088\u308b\u6e05\u660e\u4ee3\u5c0f\u8aac\u306e\u7814\u7a76 (Tokyo: Kenbun Shuppansha, 1995), 43-44. Titles using  the phrase \u201cbu qiu ren\u201d [without outside assistance] are found only in  daily-use encyclopedias from Fujian. See Wu Huey-fang \u5433\u8559\u82b3, Wanbao  quanshu<em>: Qing Ming shiqi de minjian shenghuo shilu<\/em>  \u842c\u5bf6\u5168\u66f8\uff1a\u660e\u6e05\u6642\u671f\u7684\u6c11\u554f\u751f\u6d3b\u5be6\u9304 (Taipei: Guoli Zhengzhi Daxue Chubanshe, 2001),  641-658. On dating the setting of the work, see See Xu Fuling \u5f90\u5fa9\u5dba,  Xingshi yinyuan zhuan <em>zuozhe he yuyan kaolun<\/em> \u9192\u4e16\u59fb\u7de3\u5085\u4f5c\u8005\u548c\u8a9e\u8a00\u8003\u8ad6 (Jinan: Qilu Shushe, 1993), 1-31.<\/li><li><em>Qianzi wen<\/em>, <em>Sanzi jing<\/em>, and <em>Baijia xing<\/em>  are the most common children\u2019s books of the Ming and Qing dynasties.  Once familiar with these texts, the reader can recognize a thousand  characters. See Evelyn S. Rawski, \u201cEconomic and social foundations of  late imperial China,\u201d in <em>Popular Culture in Late Imperial China<\/em>, eds. David Johnson, Andrew J Nathan and Evelyn S. Rawski (Berkeley: University of California oppress, 1985), 29-31.<\/li><li>See Su Dongfa \u856d\u6771\u767c, \u201cFuyang Yu Shi keshu kaol\u00fc (zhong)\u201d \u5efa\u967d\u4f59\u6c0f\u523b\u66f8\u8003\u7565(\u4e2d), <em>Wenxian<\/em> \u6587\u737b 22 (1984): 215; Su Dongfa \u856d\u6771\u767c, \u201cFuyang Yu Shi keshu kaol\u00fc (xia)\u201d \u5efa\u967d\u4f59\u6c0f\u523b\u66f8\u8003\u7565(\u4e0b), <em>Wenxian<\/em> \u6587\u737b 23 (1985): 244-246; Miao Yonghe \u7e46\u548f\u79be, <em>Ming dai chuban shi gao<\/em> \u660e\u4ee3\u51fa\u7248\u53f2\u7a3f (Nanjing: Jiangsu Renmin Chubanshe, 2000), 392; Kin Bunky\u014d \u91d1\u6587\u4eac, \u201cTang Binyin yu wan Ming shangye chuban\u201d \u6e6f\u8cd3\u5c39\u8207\u665a\u660e\u5546\u696d\u51fa\u7248, in <em>Shibian yu weixin: Wan Ming yu wan Qing de wenxue yishu<\/em>  \u4e16\u8b8a\u8207\u7dad\u65b0\uff1a\u665a\u660e\u8207\u665a\u6e05\u7684\u6587\u5b78\u85dd\u8853, ed. Hu Siao-chen \u80e1\u66c9\u771f (Taipei: Zhongyang Yanjiuyuan  Zhongguo Wen Zhe Yanjiusuo Choubeichu, 2001), 81-83; Chia, <em>Printing for Profit,<\/em> 149-150, 250-253.<\/li><li>Ko, <em>Teachers of the Inner Chambers,<\/em> 34-41.<\/li><li>Evelyn S. Rawski, <em>Education and Popular Literacy in Ch<\/em> \u2018<em>ing China<\/em>  (Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, 1979), 1-17; David Johnson,  \u201cCommunication, Class, and Consciousness in Late Imperial China,\u201d in  Johnson et al, <em>Popular Culture in Late Imperial China,<\/em> 38-39,  54-65; James Hayes, \u201cSpecialists and Written Materials in the Village  World,\u201d 93-111; Grace S. Fong, \u201cFemale Hands: Embroidery as a Knowledge  Field in Women\u2019s Everyday Life in Late Imperial and Early Republican China\u201d (paper presented at <em>Shenghuo, zhishi yu Zhongguo xiandaixing: Guoji xueshu yantaohui<\/em> \u300c\u751f\u6d3b\u3001\u77e5\u8b58\u8207\u4e2d\u570b\u73fe\u4ee3\u6027\u300d\u570b\u969b\u5b78\u8853\u7814\u8a0e\u6703, Institute of Modern History, Academia Sinica, Taipei, 21-23 November, 2002).<\/li><li>Johnson, \u201cCommunication, class, and consciousness in late imperial China,\u201d 55-67.<\/li><li>See Sakade Yoshinobu \u5742\u51fa\u7965\u4f38, \u201cKaisetsu: Min dai nichiy\u014d ruisho ni tsuite,\u201d \u89e3\u8aac\u2014\u2014\u660e\u4ee3\u65e5\u7528\u985e\u66f8\u306b\u3064\u3044\u3066, in <em>Ch\u016bgoku nichiy\u014d ruisho sh\u016bsei<\/em> \u4e2d\u56fd\u65e5\u7528\u985e\u66f8\u96c6, vol. 1, <em>Xinqie quanbu tianxia simin liyong bianguan wuche bajin<\/em>  \u65b0\u9365\u5168\u88dc\u5929\u4e0b\u56db\u6c11\u5229\u7528\u4fbf\u89c0\u4e94\u8eca\u62d4\u9326 (serial woodblock edition of 1597; Tokyo: Ky\u016bko Shoin,  1999), 7-8. The \u201cfour classes of the people\u201d are scholars, farmers,  artisans, and merchants.<\/li><li>James Cahill, <em>The Painter\u2019s Practice: How Artists and Lived and Worked in Traditional China<\/em>  (New York: Columbia University Press, 1994), 35-39; Ann Burkus-Chasson,  \u201cElegant or Common? Chen Hongshou\u2019s Birthday Presentation Pictures and  His Professional Status,\u201d in <em>Art Bulletin<\/em> 76:2 (June 1994): 285-298.<\/li><li>See Xu, <em>Wanjuan xingluo<\/em>, j. 19: 12; <em>Wuche bajin<\/em> \u4e94\u8eca\u62d4\u9326, in <em>Ch\u016bgoku nichiy\u014d ruisho sh\u016bsei<\/em>, 2: 36-37.<\/li><li>There are a number of studies concerning portraits of ancestors, for example Jan Stuart, \u201cIntroduction,\u201d in <em>Worshipping the ancestors: Chinese commemorative portraits<\/em>,  ed. Jan Stuart and Evelyn S. Rawski (Washington D.C.: Smithsonian  Institution, 2001), 15-116. For a different sort of study of portraits,  see Li Guoan \u674e\u570b\u5b89, \u201cMing wei xiaoxianghua zhizuo de liangge shehui  tezheng\u201d \u660e\u672b\u8096\u50cf\u7ae0\u88fd\u4f5c\u7684\u5169\u500b\u793e\u6703\u7279\u5fb5, <em>Yishuxue<\/em> \u85dd\u8853\u5b78 6 (1991): 119-156;  Cheng-hua Wang, \u201cMaterial culture and emperorship: The shaping of  imperial roles at the court of Xuanzong (r. 1426-1435)\u201d (PhD diss., Yale  University, 1998), j. 4; Yu Hui \u4f59\u8f1d, \u201cShiqi, shiba shiji de shimin  xiaoxianghua\u201d \u5341\u4e03\u3001\u5341\u516b\u4e16\u7d00\u7684\u5e02\u6c11\u8096\u50cf\u756b, <em>Gugong Bowuyuan yuankan<\/em> \u6545\u5bae\u535a\u7269\u9662\u9662\u520a 3 (2001): 38-41.<\/li><li>Wang Yi \u738b\u7e79, <em>Xiexiang mijue<\/em> \u5beb\u50cf\u7955\u8a23, in <em>Hualun congkan<\/em>  \u756b\u8ad6\u53e2\u520a, ed. An Lan \u5b89\u703e (Beijing: Renmin Meishu Chubanshe, 1960), 852-855.  The history of portraiture can be traced back to the Northern Song  (960-1126) and even earlier, but no texts survive from these periods.<\/li><li>See Xu, <em>Wanjuan xingluo<\/em>, j. 7: 7.<\/li><li>Ibid., 11; <em>Wuche bajin<\/em>, in <em>Ch\u016bgoku nichiy\u014d ruisho sh\u016bsei<\/em>, 1: 353-354; Li guangyu \u674e\u5149\u88d5, ed., <em>Dingjuan Li Xiansheng zengbu simin shiyong jiyu quanshu<\/em>  \u9f0e\u9d3f\u674e\u5148\u751f\u589e\u88dc\u56db\u6c11\u4f7f\u7528\u7a4d\u7389\u5168\u66f8 (woodblock edition from the reign of the Ming dynasty  Chongzhen emperor [1611-1644]) (Beijing: held by the National Library of  China) j. 12: 11-12; <em>Wanshu yuanhai<\/em> \u842c\u66f8\u6df5\u6d77, in <em>Ch\u016bgoku nichiy\u014d ruisho sh\u016bsei<\/em>, 6: 276.<\/li><li>See Xu, <em>Wanjuan xingluo<\/em>, 7: 10.<\/li><li>James Cahill, The Painter\u2019s Practice: How Artists Lived  and Worked in Traditional China (New York: Columbia University Press,  1994), 19-24, 33-35; Shih Shou-Chien \u77f3\u5b88\u8b19, \u201cWen Zhengming yu dazhong  wenhua\u201d \u6587\u5fb5\u660e\u8207\u5927\u773e\u6587\u5316, in Taiwan 2002-nian Dongya Huihua Shi Yantaohui lunwen  ji \u53f0\u70632002 \u5e74\u6771\u4e9e\u7e6a\u756b\u53f2\u7814\u8a0e\u6703\u8ad6\u6587\u96c6 (Taipei: Graduate Institute of Art History,  National Taiwan University, 2002), 193-206. See also Qiu Zhonglin \u90b1\u4ef2\u9e9f,  \u201cDanri chengshang: Ming Qing shehui de qingshou wenhua\u201d \u8a95\u65e5\u7a31\u6ba4\u4e00\u660e\u6e05\u793e\u6703\u7684\u6176\u58fd\u6587\u5316,  Xin shixue \u65b0\u53f2\u5b78 11: 3 (Sept. 2000).<\/li><li>See Liu Ruoyu \u5289\u82e5\u611a, <em>Zhuo zhong zhi<\/em> \u914c\u4e2d\u5fd7  (Beijing: Beijing Guji Chubanshe, 1994), 177-184. Translator\u2019s note:  Tian Guan and Zhong Kui were Daoist deities. Tian Guan, the \u201cofficial of  heaven,\u201d was believed to bring blessings. Zhong Kui was worshipped for  his skill in quelling demons. The five poisonous creatures were  scorpions, vipers, centipedes, lizards, and toads; it was believed that  these five harmful creatures would begin appearing on the Dragon Boat  Festival, which takes place on the fifth day of the fifth lunar month,  unless preventive measures were taken.<\/li><li>Translator\u2019s note: The herb mugwort was believed to repel the five poisonous creatures.<\/li><li>See Wen Zhenheng \u6587\u9707\u4ea8, <em>Zhang wu zhi jiaozhu<\/em> \u9577\u7269\u5fd7\u6821\u6ce8 (Jiangsu: Jiangsu Kexue Jishu Chubanshe, 1984), 222-224.<\/li><li>James Cahill, <em>The Painter\u2019s Practice<\/em>, 35-45.<\/li><li>Xu, <em>Wanjuan xingluo<\/em>, j. 7: 11.<\/li><li>Translator\u2019s note: \u201cAlong the River during the Qingming  festival,\u201d originally the work of Song dynasty artist Zhang Zeduan  (1085-1145). Countless copies of this extremely famous work were  produced.<\/li><li>For materials concerning transactions of \u201cQingming shang he tu\u201d in Beijing, see Li Rihua \u674e\u65e5\u83ef, <em>Weishui Xuan riji<\/em> \u5473\u6c34\u8ed2\u65e5\u8a18, vol. 39 in <em>Congshu jicheng jibian: Shi bu<\/em> \u300a\u53e2\u66f8\u96c6\u6210\u7e3e\u7de8\u300b\uff0c\u53f2\u90e8 (Shanghai: Shanghai Shudian, 1994), 739-740, and <em>Zitao Xuan youzhui<\/em> \u7d2b\u6843\u8ed2\u53c8\u7db4, vol. 89 in <em>Congshu jicheng jibian: Zi bu<\/em>\u300a\u53e2\u66f8\u96c6\u6210\u7e3e\u7de8\u300b\uff0c\u5b50\u90e8, 400. For biographical materials on Li Rihua, see Zhang, <em>Ming shi<\/em>, 7400.<\/li><li>On transactions of paintings and works of calligraphy  in major cities in the Tang and Northern Song dynasties, see Michael  Sullivan, \u201cSome notes on the social history of Chinese art,\u201d <em>Zhongyang Yanjiuyuan Guoji Hanxuehui yilunwen ji: Yishu shi zu<\/em> \u300a\u4e2d\u592e\u7814\u7a76\u9662\u570b\u969b\u6f22\u5b78\u6703\u8b70\u8ad6\u6587\u96c6\u300b\uff0c\u85dd\u8853\u53f2\u7d44 (Taipei: Academia Sinica, 1980).<\/li><li>See Craig Clunas, <em>Superfluous Things: Material Culture and Social Status in Early Modern China<\/em> (Urbana and Chicago: University of Illinois Press, 1991), 133-137; James Cahill, <em>The Painter<\/em> \u2018s <em>Practice,<\/em> 45-50.<\/li><li>Numerous images of cities from the late-Ming dynasty  specifically depict locations where paintings and works of calligraphy  changed hands, including \u201cHuangdu jisheng tu\u201d \u7687\u6597\u7a4d\u52dd\u5716, \u201cNandu fanhui\u201d  \u5357\u90fd\u7e41\u6703, \u201cShangyuan dengcai\u201d \u4e0a\u5143\u71c8\u5f69, and numerous versions of \u201cQingming shang  he tu.\u201d<\/li><li>See Chen Yuanjing, <em>Shilin guangji<\/em>, j. 9, final scroll: 180-187.<\/li><li>The inclusion of Mongolian script might date back to the original edition of the <em>Shilin guangji,<\/em>  which was published after the Mongols had conquered north China; the  Mongols remained a serious threat to the Ming through the fifteenth  century.<\/li><li>For example, <em>Wanshu yuanhai<\/em>, in <em>Ch\u016bgoku nichiy\u014d ruisho sh\u016bsei<\/em>, 6: 433-445; Chen Yun-chung \u9673\u5141\u4e2d, ed., <em>Xinke qunshu zhaiyao shimin bianyong yishi bu qiu ren<\/em>  \u65b0\u523b\u7fa4\u66f8\u6458\u8981\u58eb\u6c11\u4fbf\u7528\u4e00\u4e8b\u4e0d\u6c42\u4eba (Ming dynasty Wanli era woodblock edition; held by the  Tanimura Archive of the Kyoto University Library, Kyoto), j. 18: 1-15;  Zheng Shangxuan \u912d\u5c1a\u7384, ed., <em>Xinke Renruitang dingbu quanshu beikao<\/em>  \u65b0\u523b\u4eba\u745e\u5802\u8a02\u88dc\u5168\u66f8\u5099\u8003 (Ming dynasty Chongwen era serial woodblock edition;  Taipei: in the collection of the Fu Ssu-nien Library of the Institute of  History and Philology, Academia Sinica, originally held by the Kyoto  University Research Centre for the Cultural Sciences), j. 10: 7.<\/li><li>On the vogue for calligraphy and important publications in the late Ming, see Qianshen Bai, <em>Fu Shan\u2019s World: The Transformation of Chinese Calligraphy in the Seventeenth Century<\/em> (Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press, 2003), 10-71.<\/li><li>See Bai Qianshen \u767d\u8b19\u614e, \u201cMing mo Qing chu shufa zhong shuxie yitizi fengqi de yanjiu\u201d \u660e\u672b\u6e05\u521d\u66f8\u6cd5\u4e2d\u66f8\u5beb\u7570\u9ad4\u5b57\u98a8\u6c23\u7684\u7814\u7a76, <em>Shulun<\/em>  \u66f8\u8ad6 32 (2001): 181-187; Ibid., 67. At the time, \u201cunusual characters\u201d  often referred to multiple alternate versions of characters found in  seal and clerical scripts, or to characters that could be written in a  variety of ways, as in Zhu Mouwei \u6731\u8b00\u744b, <em>Guwen qizi<\/em> \u53e4\u6587\u5947\u5b57, in <em>Siku weishou shuji kan<\/em> \u56db\u5eab\u672a\u6536\u66f8\u8f2f\u520a (Beijing: Beijing Chubanshe, 1997), part 2, vol. 14: 105-186; Guo Yijing \u90ed\u4e00\u7d93, <em>Zixue san zheng<\/em> \u5b57\u5b78\u4e09\u6b63, in <em>Siku weishou shuji kan<\/em>, part 2, vol. 14, 187-348; Zhao Yiguang \u8d99\u5b9c\u5149, <em>Shuowen changjian<\/em> \u8aaa\u6587\u9577\u7b8b, in <em>Siku quanshu cunmu congshu<\/em> \u56db\u5eab\u5168\u66f8\u5b58\u76ee\u53e2\u66f8, Jing bu \u7d93\u90e8 [Classics section], vol. 195 and 196.<\/li><li>There are exceptions; the <em>Jiyu quanshu<\/em> edition held by the National Library of China in Beijing prints <em>Qian zi wen<\/em> in <em>kai shu<\/em>, <em>cao shu<\/em>, seal script, and <em>li shu<\/em> attributed to famed mid-Ming calligrapher Wen Zhengming. Li, <em>Jiyu quanshu<\/em>, <em>j<\/em>. 10: 1-15.<\/li><li>According to Han Fangming \u97d3\u65b9\u540d (fl. 8<sup>th<\/sup> c.), well-known calligrapher of the Tang dynasty, the eight representative strokes are of an extremely early origin. See his <em>Shou bi yao shuo<\/em> \u6388\u7b46\u8981\u8aaa, in <em>Lidai shufa lunwen xuan<\/em> \u6b77\u4ee3\u66f8\u6cd5\u8ad6\u6587\u9078 (Shanghai: Shanghai Shuhua Chubanshe, 1981), 286.<\/li><li><em>Jujia biyong shilei quanji<\/em>, A: 30-33. Regarding the legend of the \u201cextraordinary eight-stroke method,\u201d see Fushimi Ch\u016bkei \u4f0f\u898b\u51b2\u656c, \u201cYongzi bafa\u201d \u6c38\u5b57\u516b\u6cd5, in <em>Shod\u014d shi tenby\u014d<\/em>  \u66f8\u9053\u53f2\u9ede\u63cf (Tokyo: Nigensha, 1979), 145-158. Thank you to my classmate He  Yan-chiuan of the Graduate Institute of Art History, National Taiwan  University for making me aware of this text.<\/li><li><em>Jujia bibei<\/em>, Yixue shang \u85dd\u5b78\u4e0a [Arts section 1], <em>j<\/em>. 8: 1-3..<\/li><li>See Feng Fang \u8c50\u574a, <em>Tongxue shucheng<\/em> \u7ae5\u5b78\u66f8\u7a0b [Calligraphy study course for children], in <em>Ming Qing shufa lunwen xuan<\/em> \u660e\u6e05\u66f8\u6cd5\u8ad6\u6587\u9078 (Shanghai: Shanghai Shuju Chubanshe, 1995), 97-102.<\/li><li>Wang and Wang, <em>Assembled Illustrations of the Three Realms<\/em>,  Renshi juan 4 \u4eba\u4e8b\u53774 [Human affairs chapter 4]: 16. Dong Qichang also  recommends that instructional texts begin with standard writing  techniques; see Wang Qingzheng \u6c6a\u6176\u6b63, \u201cDong Qichang fashu ketie jianshu\u201d  \u8463\u5176\u660c\u6cd5\u66f8\u523b\u5e16\u7c21\u8ff0, in Wai-kam Ho, ed., <em>The Century of Tung Ch\u2019i-chang 1555-1636<\/em> (Kansas City: The Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art, 1994), 2: 337.<\/li><li><em>Wanshu yuanhai<\/em>, j. 15: 2-14; <em>Wuche bajin<\/em>, j. 13: 1-34; Xu, <em>Wanjuan xingluo<\/em>, j. 15: 1-13; <em>Wanbao quanshu<\/em>, j. 11: 2-7; Wang and Wang, <em>Sancai tuhui<\/em>, \u201cRenshi juan 3\u201d \u4eba\u4e8b\u53773 [Human affairs chapter 3]: 2-15.<\/li><li>For instance, Chen, <em>Xinke qunshu zhaiyao shimin bianyong yishi buqiu ren<\/em>, j. 18:1-6.<\/li><li>Regarding the circulation of late-Ming calligraphic works and practice models, see \u014cno Sh\u016bsaku \u5927\u91ce\u4fee\u4f5c, <em>Shoron to Ch\u016bgoku bungaku\u3000<\/em>\u66f8\u8ad6 \u3068\u4e2d\u56fd\u6587\u5b66 (Tokyo: Kenbun Shuppansha, 2001), 262-264; Wang Jingxian \u738b\u9756\u61b2, \u201cMing dai congtie zongshu\u201d \u660e\u4ee3\u53e2\u5e16\u7d9c\u8ff0, in <em>Zhongguo fatie quanji<\/em>  \u4e2d\u570b\u6cd5\u5e16\u5168\u96c6, Qi Gong \u555f\u529f, Wang Jingxian \u738b\u9756\u61b2, eds. (Wuhan: Hubai Meishu  Chubanshe, 2002), 13: 1-2; Masuda Tomoyuki \u5897\u7530\u77e5\u4e4b, \u201cMin dai ni okeru h\u014dj\u014d  no kank\u014d to Sosh\u016b fumiuji ichizoku\u201d \u660e\u4ee3\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u6cd5\u5e16\u306e\u520a\u884c\u3068\u8607\u5dde\u6587\u6c0f\u4e00\u65cf, <em>T\u014dy\u014d shi kenky\u016b<\/em> \u6771\u6d0b\u53f2\u7814\u7a76 62:1 (July 2003), 43-48.<\/li><li>For instance, Chen, <em>Xinke qunshu zhaiyao shimin bianyong yishi bu qiu ren<\/em>, j. 18, 1; <em>Dingqin Chongwen Ge huizuan shimin jieyong fenlei xuefu quanbian<\/em>  \u9f0e\u92df\u5d07\u6587\u95a3\u5f59\u7e82\u58eb\u6c11\u6377\u7528\u5206\u985e\u5b78\u5e9c\u5168\u7de8 (1607 Ming woodblock edition; Taipei: facsimile  edition held by the Fu Ssu-nien Library of the Institute of History and  Philology, Academia Sinica, originally held by the Institute of Advanced  Studies on Asia, The University of Tokyo), j. 16: 1.<\/li><li>With regard to the shifting social identities of the  late Ming, see Kishimoto Mio \u5cb8\u672c\u7f8e\u7dd2, \u201cMin Shin jidai no mibun kankaku\u201d  \u660e\u6e05\u6642\u4ee3\u306e\u8eab\u5206\u611f\u899a, in <em>Min Shin jidai shi no kihon mondai<\/em> \u660e\u6e05\u6642\u4ee3\u53f2\u306e\u57fa\u672c\u554f\u984c  (Tokyo: Ky\u016bko Shoin, 1997), 403-428; Wang, \u201cLiudong yu hudong: You Ming  Qing jian chengshi shenghuo de texing tance gongzhong changyu de  zhankai,\u201d j. 2.<\/li><li>Translator\u2019s note: This term distinguishes \u201cliterati\u201d  painters, men of education and culture who practiced painting as a  pastime from professional artists who worked for a living.<\/li><li>See Wang Cheng-hua \u738b\u6b63\u83ef, \u201cCong Chen Honghuan de <em>Hua lun<\/em> kan wan Ming Zhejiang huatan: Jian lun Jiangnan huihua wangluo yu quyu jingzheng\u201d \u5f9e\u9673\u6d2a\u7de9\u7684\u300a\u756b\u8ad6\u300b\u770b\u665a\u660e\u6f38\u6c5f\u756b\u58c7\uff1a\u517c\u8ad6\u6c5f\u5357\u7e6a\u756b\u7db2\u7d61\u8207\u5340\u57df\u7af6\u722d, in <em>Quyu yu wangluo: Jin Qian Nian Lai Zhongguo Meishu Shi Yanjiu Guoji Xueshu Yantaohui lunwen ji<\/em> \u5340\u57df\u8207\u7db2\u7d61\uff1a\u8fd1\u5343\u5e74\u4f86\u4e2d\u570b\u7f8e\u8853\u53f2\u7814\u7a76\u570b\u969b\u5b78\u8853\u7814\u8a0e\u6703\u8ad6\u6587\u96c6 (Taipei: Graduate Institute of Art History, National Taiwan University, 2001), 339-353.<\/li><li>These are: <em>Dreaming of the Mountain of Floating Silk<\/em> (<em>Luo fu huan zhi<\/em> \u7f85\u6d6e\u5e7b\u8cea), on drawing plums; <em>Lingering Beauty of the Nine Fields (Jiu wan yirong<\/em> \u4e5d\u7579\u907a\u5bb9), on drawing orchids; and <em>Chirping and Flying in a Spring Valley (Chun gu ying xiang<\/em> \u6625\u8c37\u56b6\u7fd4), on drawing birds, etc. Wang and Wang, <em>Sancai tuhui<\/em>, Ren shi juan 4 \u4eba\u4e8b\u53774 [Human affairs chapter 4]: 27-40. Zhou L\u00fcjing \u5468\u5c65\u9756, \u201cLuo fu huan zhi\u201d \u7f85\u6d6e\u5e7b\u8cea, in <em>Zhongguo lidai huapu hui bian<\/em> \u4e2d\u570b\u6b77\u4ee3\u756b\u8b5c\u532f\u7de8 (Tianjin: Tianjin Guji Chubanshe, 1997), 14: 697-736; Zhou L\u00fcjing \u5468\u5c65\u9756, \u201cChun gu ying xiang\u201d \u6625\u8c37\u56b6\u7fd4, <em>Zhongguo lidai huapu hui bian<\/em>, 13: 437-484.<\/li><li>In the Southern Song and Yuan dynasties these became  standard, popular subjects for painting. Song Boren \u5b8b\u4f2f\u4ec1, \u201cMeihua xishen  pu\u201d \u6885\u82b1\u559c\u795e\u8b5c, <em>Zhongguo lidai huapu hui bian<\/em> \u4e2d\u570b\u6b77\u4ee3\u756b\u8b5c\u532f\u7de8, 14: 347-500; Li Kan \u674e\u884e, <em>Zhu pu<\/em> \u7af9\u8b5c, in <em>Zhongguo lidai huapu hui bian<\/em>, 16: 133-234. For related research, see Shimada Sh\u016bjir\u014d \u5cf6\u7530\u4fee\u4e8c\u90ce, \u201c<em>Song Zhai huapu<\/em> kaidai\u201d \u300a\u677e\u9f4b\u6885\u8b5c\u300b \u89e3\u984c in <em>Song Zhai meipu<\/em> \u677e\u9f4b\u6885\u8b5c (Hiroshima: Hiroshima City Central Library, 1988), 3-37; Chen Dexin \u9673\u5fb7\u99a8, \u201c<em>Meihua xishen pu<\/em> yanjiu\u201d \u300a\u6885\u82b1\u559c\u795e\u8b5c\u300b\u7814\u7a76, (Master\u2019s thesis, National Taiwan University, Taipei, 1996), 74-80; Maggie Bickford, <em>Ink Plum: The Making of a Chinese Scholar-painting Genre<\/em> (Cambridge UK: Cambridge University Press, 1996), 180-196; Chen Dexin, \u201c<em>Meihua xishen pu:<\/em> Song Boren de ziwo tuijian shu\u201d \u300a\u6885\u82b1\u559c\u795e\u8b5c\u300b\u2014\u2014\u5b8b\u4f2f\u4ec1\u7684\u81ea\u6211\u63a8\u85a6\u66f8, <em>Meishu shi yanjiu jikan<\/em> \u7f8e\u8853\u53f2\u7814\u7a76\u96c6\u520a 5 (1998), 123-152.<\/li><li>For exceptions, see <em>Xin qie tianxia bei lan wenlin lei ji wanshu cuibao<\/em>  \u65b0\u9365\u5929\u4e0b\u5099\u89bd\u6587\u6797\u985e\u8a18\u842c\u66f8\u8403\u5bf6 (1596 woodblock edition; Taipei, facsimile edition held  by Fu Ssu-nien Library of the Institute of History and Philology,  Academia Sinica, originally held by the Institute of Advanced Studies on  Asia, The University of Tokyo), j. 16: 5-15; Zheng, <em>Xinke Renruitang dingbu quanshu beikao<\/em>,  j. 8: 7-8. The former includes pictures of chrysanthemums, people, and  animals, and the latter generally depicts orchids, people, and animals,  but in both cases the quantity of pictures is low.<\/li><li><em>Wuche wanbao quanshu<\/em>, j. 11: 16-19.<\/li><li>See Gu Bing \u9867\u70b3, <em>Gu Shi huapu<\/em>\u9867\u6c0f\u756b\u8b5c (Beijing:  Wenwu Chubanshe, 1983). Qi Chengye (1565-1628) was from Shanyin,  Zhejiang, passed the highest imperial examination in 1604, and was the  father of Qi Biaojia. For biographical sketches, see Zhu Yizun \u6731\u5f5d\u5c0a, <em>Ming shi zong<\/em> \u660e\u8a69\u7d9c, j. 59: 23; Zhu Yizun, <em>Jing zhi jushi hua<\/em> \u975c\u5fd7\u5c45\u8a69\u8a71, in <em>Xuxiu siku quanshu<\/em>,  vol. 1698, j. 16, 37-38. The writings attributed to Qi Chengye are  likely not by him; the attribution should be treated with suspicion.<\/li><li>See Clunas, <em>Pictures and visuality in early modern China<\/em>, 134-148.<\/li><li>On the spread of Tang poetry in the late Ming, see Liu Qiaomei \u5289\u5de7\u6963, <em>Wan Ming Suzhou huihua<\/em>  \u665a\u660e\u8607\u5dde\u7e6a\u756b (Master\u2019s thesis, National Taiwan University Graduate School of  History, Taipei, 1989), 115-117; Tang Guoqiu \u5510\u570b\u7403, \u201cShilun <em>Tang shi gui<\/em> de bianji, banxing ji qi shixue yiyi\u201d \u8a66\u8ad6\ufe5b\u5510\u8a69\u6b78\ufe5c\u7684\u7de8\u96c6\u3001\u7248\u884c\u53ca\u5176\u8a69\u5b78\u610f\u7fa9, in in <em>Shibian yu weixin: Wan Ming yu wan Qing de wenxue yishu<\/em> \u4e16\u8b8a\u8207\u7dad\u65b0\uff1a\u665a\u660e\u8207\u665a\u6e05\u7684\u6587\u5b78\u85dd\u8853, ed. Hu Siao-chen \u80e1\u66c9\u771f (Taipei: Zhongyang Yanjiuyuan Zhongguo Wen Zhe Yanjiusuo Choubeichu, 2001), 32-42.<\/li><li>See Huang Fengchi \u9ec3\u9cf3\u6c60, ed., <em>Tang shi huapu<\/em> \u5510\u8a69\u756b\u8b5c, in <em>Zhongguo gudai banhua congkan er bian<\/em> \u4e2d\u570b\u53e4\u4ee3\u7248\u756b\u53e2\u520a\u4e8c\u7de8 (Shanghai: Shanghai Guji Chubanshe, 1994).<\/li><li>For an exception, see Zheng, <em>Xinke Renruitang dingbu quanshu beikao<\/em>,  j. 8: 1-6. The paintings in this woodblock painting manual are the best  of any extant edition. Presented as fan-shaped book inserts, they are  highly characteristic of Southern Song dynasty paintings.<\/li><li>Another way in which the publishers advertised the  up-to-date quality of their works was the use of color. The \u201cBarbarians\u201d  (\u201cZhuyi\u201d \u8af8\u5937) sections of some of the encyclopedias were even reproduced  in red ink, presumably to display to the reader that the works were  produced with the most advanced print technology available in the late  Ming. Otherwise, there would have been no reason to employ such a costly  technique to such a minor effect. For instance, Bo Lanzi \u535a\u89bd\u5b50, ed., <em>Ding juan shier fangjia canding wanshi bu qiu ren Bo kao quanshu<\/em> \u9f0e\u942b\u5341\u4e8c\u65b9\u5bb6\u53c3\u8a02\u842c\u4e8b\u4e0d\u6c42\u4eba\u535a\u8003\u5168\u66f8 (Wanli era woodblock edition; Beijing: held by the National Library of China), j. 2.<\/li><li>Translator\u2019s note: \u201cZidi\u201d \u5b50\u5f1f, literally \u201csons and  younger brothers,\u201d referred at this time to the profligate sons of men  of privilege \u2014 usually officials \u2014 who took advantage of their fathers\u2019  wealth and status to live a life of idle luxury. In some daily-use  encyclopedias, the section explaining brothel etiquette was titled \u201cZidi  men\u201d \u5b50\u5f1f\u9580.<\/li><li>See Wang, \u201cCong Chen Honghuan de <em>Hua lun<\/em> kan wan Ming Zhejiang huatan,\u201d 339-353. Also see Inoue Mitsuyuki \u4e95\u4e0a\u5145\u5e78, \u201cMin matsu no bunjin Li Rihua no shumi seikatsu: <em>Weishui Xuan riji<\/em> o ch\u016bshin ni\u201d \u660e\u672b\u306e\u6587\u4eba\u674e\u65e5\u83ef\u306e\u8da3\u5473\u751f\u6d3b\u2014\u2014\u300c\u5473\u6c34\u8ed2\u65e5\u8a18\u300d\u3092\u4e2d\u5fc3\u306b, <em>T\u014dy\u014d shi kenky\u016b<\/em> \u6771\u6d0b\u53f2\u7814\u7a76 59: 1 (June 2000): 1-28.<\/li><li>For information on Dong Qichang\u2019s commentary on paintings and calligraphy as well as related works, see Fu Shen \u5085\u7533, \u201c<em>Hua shuo<\/em> zuozhe yanjiu\u201d \u300a\u756b\u8aaa\u300b\u4f5c\u8005\u7814\u7a76, in <em>Dong Qichang yanjiu wen ji<\/em> \u8463\u5176\u660c\u7814\u7a76\u6587\u96c6 (Shanghai: Shanghai Shuhua Chubanshe, 1998), 44; Wang Shiqing \u6c6a\u4e16\u6df8, \u201c<em>Hua shuo<\/em> jiu wei shei zhu\u201d \u300a\u756b\u8aaa\u300b\u7a76\u70ba\u8ab0\u8457, in <em>Dong Qichang yanjiu wen ji<\/em>, 61-62; Zhang Zining \u5f35\u5b50\u5be7, \u201cDong Qichang yu <em>Tang Song Yuan huace<\/em>\u201d \u8463\u5176\u660c\u8207\u300a\u5510\u5b8b\u5143\u756b\u518a\u300b, in <em>Dong Qichang yanjiu wen ji<\/em>, 581-590.<\/li><li>Craig Clunas, <em>Superfluous things<\/em>, j. 1-3; Wang  Cheng-hua \u738b\u6b63\u83ef, \u201cN\u00fcren, wupin yu ganguan yuwang: Chen Honghuan wanqi  renwu hua zhong Jiangnan wenhua de chengxian\u201d  \u5973\u4eba\u3001\u7269\u54c1\u8207\u611f\u5b98\u617e\u671b\uff1a\u9673\u6d2a\u7de9\u665a\u671f\u4eba\u7269\u756b\u4e2d\u6c5f\u5357\u6587\u5316\u7684\u5448\u73fe, <em>Jindai Zhongguo fun\u00fc shi yanjiu<\/em> \u8fd1\u4ee3\u4e2d\u570b\u5a66\u5973\u53f2\u7814\u7a76 10 (Dec. 2002), 12-16, 25-51.<\/li><li>See Wen Zhenheng, <em>Zhang wu zhi jiaozhu<\/em>, 10-11.<\/li><li>Ibid, 135. Regarding the distinction between appreciative audiences and the curious, see also Xie Zhaozhe \u8b1d\u8087\u6ddb, <em>Wu za zu<\/em> \u4e94\u96dc\u4fce, in <em>Lidai biji xiaoshuo jicheng<\/em> \u6b77\u4ee3\u7b46\u8a18\u5c0f\u8aaa\u96c6\u6210 (Shijiazhuang: Hebei Jiaoyu Chubanshe, 1995), vol. 54, j. 7: 26; Shen Defu \u6c88\u5fb7\u7b26, <em>Wanli yehuo bian<\/em> \u842c\u66c6\u91ce\u7372\u7de8, in <em>Yuan Ming shiliao biji<\/em> \u5143\u660e\u53f2\u6599\u7b46\u8a18 (Beijing: Zhonghua Shuju, 1997), j. 26: 653-656.<\/li><li>See Wang Hung-tai \u738b\u9d3b\u6cf0, \u201cMing Qing shiren de shenghuo  jingying yu yasu de bianzheng\u201d \u660e\u6e05\u58eb\u4eba\u7684\u751f\u6d3b\u7d93\u71df\u8207\u96c5\u4fd7\u7684\u8faf\u8b49 (paper presented at  Discourses and Practices of Everyday Life in Imperial China, a  conference organized by Academia Sinica and Columbia University, 25-27  Oct. 2002).<\/li><li>See Wen, <em>Zhang wu zhi jiaozhu<\/em>, 185-188, 221.<\/li><li>See <em>Jujia biyong shilei quanji<\/em>, A: 33-40. This book also contains a text called <em>Dong Neizhi shu jue<\/em> \u8463\u5167\u76f4\u66f8\u8a23<em>,<\/em> which is of unknown origin. For Zhang Kui\u2019s text, see <em>Lidai shufa wenlun ji<\/em>, 383-395.<\/li><li><em>Jujia bibei<\/em>, j. 8, 3-8. For Ouyang Xun\u2019s text, see <em>Lidai shufa wenlun ji<\/em>, 99-104.<\/li><li>Wang and Wang, <em>Assembled Illustrations of the Three Realms<\/em>, Renshi juan 4 \u4eba\u4e8b\u53774 [Human affairs chapter 4]: 15-17.<\/li><li>The approach of capturing a large work in miniature is  first discussed by Dong Qichang in the preface to \u201cFang Song Yuan ren  suoben hua ji ba.\u201d The genuineness of the paintings and text of this  album are in dispute, with sources variously attributing the work to  Dong Qichang, Chen Lian, Wang Shimin, and Wang Hui, among others. In the  author\u2019s opinion, the brushwork of the numerous pictures is smooth,  skillfully contrived, and extremely suggestive of Dong Qichang. For  studies of such works, see Wen C. Fong, <em>Images of the Mind<\/em>  (Princeton: The Art Museum, Princeton University, 1984), 177-192; Kohara  Hironobu \u53e4\u539f\u5b8f\u4f38, \u201cYou guan Dong Qichang \u2018Xiao zhong xian da ce\u2019 liang  sange wenti\u201d \u6709\u95dc\u8463\u5176\u660c\u2039\u5c0f\u4e2d\u73fe\u5927\u518a\u203a\u5169\u4e09\u500b\u554f\u984c, trans. \u738b\u5efa\u5eb7 Wang Jiankang, in <em>Dong Qichang yanjiu wen ji<\/em>  \u8463\u660c\u7814\u7a76\u6587\u96c6 (Shanghai: Shanghai Shuhua Chubanshe, 1998), 594-604; Xu Bangda  \u5f90\u90a6\u9054, \u201cWang Hui \u2018Xiao zhong xian da\u2019 ce zaikao\u201d \u738b\u8f29\u300a\u5c0f\u4e2d\u73fe\u5927\u300b\u518a\u518d\u8003, in <em>Qing chu siwang huapai yanjiu<\/em> \u6e05\u521d\u56db\u738b\u756b\u6d3e\u7814\u7a76 (Shanghai: Shanghai Shuhua Chubanshe, 1993), 497-504; Zhang Zining \u5f35\u5b50\u5be7, \u201c<em>Xiao zhong xian da<\/em> xiyi\u201d \u300a\u5c0f\u4e2d\u73fe\u5927\u300b\u6790\u7591, in <em>Qing chu siwang huapai yanjiu<\/em> \u6e05\u521d\u56db\u738b\u756b\u6d3e\u7814\u7a76, 505-582; Wen C. Fong and James C. Y. Watt, <em>Possessing the past: Treasures from the National Palace Museum, Taipei<\/em> (New York: The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 1996), 474-476.<\/li><li>Translator\u2019s note: \u201cZhe\u201d is short for the name of the  province \u201cZhejiang,\u201d where the style originated; this Ming-dynasty  school of conservative, academic landscape painting would have been  easily accessible to Gu, a native of Hangzhou, Zhejiang. Literati  painters tended to be contemptuous of what they considered the outmoded  style of the Zhe school painters.<\/li><li>See Kobayashi Hiromitsu \u5c0f\u6797\u5b8f\u5149, \u201cCh\u016bgoku kaiga ni okeru hanmen no igi: <em>Gan Shi huapu<\/em> (1603 nen kan) ni miru rekidai meiga fukusei o megutte\u201d \u4e2d\u56fd\u7d75\u753b\u53f2\u306b\u304a\u3051\u308b\u7248\u9762\u306e\u610f\u7fa9\u2014\u2014\u300a\u9858\u6c0f\u753b\u8b5c\u300b(1603\u5e74\u520a\uff09\u306b\u307f\u308b\u6b74\u4ee3\u540d\u753b\u8907\u88fd\u3092\u3081\u3050\u3063\u3066, <em>Bijutsushi<\/em> \u7f8e\u8853\u53f2 128 (March 1990), 123-135.<\/li><li>Respectively, present-day Shanghai and a region  encompassing present-day Suzhou and the area around Lake Tai, in Jiangsu  province. These were the centers of literati painting in the late Ming.<\/li><li>Clunas, <em>Pictures and Visuality in Early Modern China<\/em>, 134-148.<\/li><li>Gu Bing himself regarded Zhou Zhimian \u5468\u4e4b\u5195 (1521-1610),  artist of a flower and bird painting presently held by the Palace Museum  in Beijing, as his teacher. The events of Zhou\u2019s life are recorded in  Jiang Shaoshu\u2019s \u59dc\u7d39\u66f8 early Qing work on the history of poetry entitled <em>History of Poetry without Sound<\/em> (<em>Wusheng shi shi<\/em> \u7121\u8072\u8a69\u53f2). See Kobayashi, \u201cCh\u016bgoku kaiga ni okeru hanmen no igi,\u201d 124.<\/li><li>See Liu Qiaomei \u5289\u5de7\u6963, \u201cWan Ming Suzhou huihua zhong de shi hua guanxi\u201d \u665a\u660e\u8607\u5dde\u7e6a\u756b\u4e2d\u7684\u8a69\u756b\u95dc\u4fc2, <em>Yishuxue<\/em> \u85dd\u8853\u5b78 6 (Sept. 1991), 33-103.<\/li><li>Roger Chartier, <em>The Order of Books<\/em>: <em>Readers, Authors, and Libraries in Europe between the Fourteenth and Fifteenth Centuries,<\/em> trans. Lydia G. Cochrane (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1994), 1-24; Chartier, <em>Forms and Meanings: Texts, Performances, and Audiences<\/em> <em>from Codex to Computer<\/em> (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1995), 1-24.<\/li><li>Liu Daochun \u5289\u9053\u9187, \u201cSheng chao ming hua ping xu\u201d \u8056\u671d\u540d\u756b\u8a55\u5e8f, in <em>Sheng chao ming hua ping<\/em> \u8056\u671d\u540d\u756b\u8a55, in <em>Zhongguo shu hua quanshu<\/em> (Shanghai: Shanghai Shuhua Chubanshe, 1993), 1: 446.<\/li><li>There are multiple interpretations of Xie He\u2019s six  laws. See Shih Shou-chien \u77f3\u5b88\u8b19, \u201cFu cai zhi xing: Chuantong meixue  sixiang yu yishu piping\u201d \u8ce6\u5f69\u88fd\u5f62\u2014\u2014\u50b3\u7d71\u7f8e\u5b78\u601d\u60f3\u8207\u85dd\u8853\u6279\u8a55, in <em>Meigan yu zaoxing<\/em> \u7f8e\u611f\u8207\u9020\u5f62, ed. Jason C. Kuo \u90ed\u7e7c\u751f (Taipei: Linking Publishing, 1982), 33-36.<\/li><li>Very few editions correctly print \u201cHua you liu fa\u201d rather than \u201cHua you liu ge.\u201d Among those that do is Yu Xiangdou \u4f59\u8c61\u6597, ed., <em>Santai wanyong zhengzong<\/em> \u4e09\u53f0\u842c\u7528\u6b63\u5b97 (1599 woodblock edition), in <em>Ch\u016bgoku nichiy\u014d ruisho sh\u016bsei<\/em> \u4e2d\u570b\u65e5\u7528\u985e\u66f8\u96c6\u6210 (Tokyo: Ky\u016bko Shoin, 2000), j. 12: 13.<\/li><li>Gao Lian \u9ad8\u6fc2, <em>Zun sheng ba jian jiaozhu<\/em>  \u9075\u751f\u516b\u7b8b\u6821\u6ce8, ed. Zhao Lixun \u8d99\u7acb\u52db (Beijing: Renmin Weisheng Chubanshe, 1994),  553. For information on Gao Lian\u2019s family background, life, and  education, see Clunas, <em>Superfluous Things<\/em>, 14-16.<\/li><li>Translator\u2019s note: As \u674e\u8a54\u9053 rather than \u674e\u662d\u9053; pronounced the same way, but written with the wrong character.<\/li><li>Translator\u2019s note: In the phrase \u76b4\u6cd5\u8981\u6ef2\u8edf, the character \u8edf  is mistakenly given as \u8f03 [compare], Huang Gongwang \u9ec3\u516c\u671b, \u201cXie  shanshui jue\u201d \u5beb\u5c71\u6c34\u8a23, in <em>Hualun congkan<\/em>, 55-57.<\/li><li>For information regarding the role of Gu Kaizhi, see  \u77f3\u5b88\u8b19 Shih Shou-Chien, \u201cFu cai zhi xing: Chuantong meixue sixiang yu yishu  piping\u201d \u8ce6\u5f69\u88fd\u5f62\u2014\u50b3\u7d71\u7f8e\u5b78\u601d\u60f3\u8207\u85dd\u8853\u6279\u8a55 in <em>Meigan yu zaoxing<\/em>, 25.<\/li><li>For information regarding Chen Zihe and his painting  style, see Shih Shou-Chien \u77f3\u5b88\u8b19, \u201cShen huan bianhua: You Fujian huajia  Chen Zihe kan Ming dai Daojiao shuimo hua zhi fazhan\u201d  \u795e\u5e7b\u8b8a\u5316\uff1a\u7531\u798f\u5efa\u756b\u5bb6\u9673\u5b50\u548c\u770b\u660e\u4ee3\u9053\u6559\u6c34\u58a8\u756b\u4e4b\u767c\u5c55, <em>Meishu shi yanjiu jikan<\/em> \u7f8e\u8853\u53f2\u7814\u7a76\u96c6\u520a 2 (1995): 47-74.<\/li><li>Richard Barnhart, \u201cThe Wild and Heterodox School of Ming Painting,\u201d in <em>Theories of the Arts in China<\/em>, eds. Susan Bush and Christian Murck (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1983), 365-396.<\/li><li>Roger Chartier, <em>The Cultural Uses of Print in Early Modern France<\/em>,  trans. Lydia G. Cochrane (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1987),  3-12; Roger Chartier \u201cPopular appropriation: The readers and their  books,\u201d in his <em>Forms and Meanings<\/em>, 83-98.<\/li><li>Translator\u2019s note: Texts relying on beliefs in  supernatural retribution and reward (found in Daoism, Buddhism, and  Confucianism) to urge readers to avoid evil and do good.<\/li><li>Translator\u2019s note: A genre of folk religious texts written in a mixture of prose and verse.<\/li><\/ol>\n\n\n\n<p class=\"wp-block-paragraph\">Cite: Wang Cheng-hua, \u201cLifestyles, Knowledge, and Cultural Products: Fujian Daily-Use Encyclopedias of the Late-Ming Dynasty and Their Painting and Calligraphy Sections,\u201d translated by Michael Day, <em>Lingua Franca<\/em>, Issue 6 (2020), https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/2020-wang\/.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>Wang Cheng-hua (Princeton University)1Translated by Michael Day Originally published as: Wang Cheng-hua (Wang Zhenghua). \u201cShenghuo, zhishi yu wenhua shangpin: wan Ming Fujianban riyong leishu yu qi shuhuamen\u201d \u751f\u6d3b\u77e5\u8b58\u8207\u6587\u5316\u5546\u54c1\uff1a\u665a\u660e\u798f\u5efa\u7248\u65e5\u7528\u985e\u66f8\u8207\u5176\u66f8\u756b\u9580in Zhongyang yanjiuyuan Jindaishi yanjiusuo jikan \u4e2d\u592e\u7814\u7a76\u9662\u8fd1\u4ee3\u53f2\u7814\u7a76\u6240\u96c6\u520a (Journal of the Institute of Modern History, Academia Sinica) 41 (September 2003): 1-85. Daily-Use Encyclopedias on&hellip;<\/p>\n<p class=\"more-link-wrapper\"><a class=\"more-link\" href=\"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/2020-wang\/\">Continue<\/a><\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":2,"featured_media":0,"parent":0,"menu_order":0,"comment_status":"closed","ping_status":"closed","template":"","meta":{"footnotes":""},"class_list":["post-181","page","type-page","status-publish","hentry"],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/pages\/181","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/pages"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/page"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/2"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=181"}],"version-history":[{"count":16,"href":"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/pages\/181\/revisions"}],"predecessor-version":[{"id":349,"href":"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/pages\/181\/revisions\/349"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/sharpweb.org\/linguafranca\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=181"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}